STATE OF JAMMU INDUSTRIES AND COMMERCE DEPTT. CIVIL SECRETARIAT COMMISSIONER vs M/S.JAMMU STEEL INDUSTRIES . — C.A. No. 9848/2011
Case under Section XI-B. Status: Disposed.
CNR: SCIN010007002006
Filing Date
04-Jan-2006
Registration No
C.A. No. 9848/2011
Diary Number
700/2006
Order Date
18-Aug-2017
Document Type
Judgement - of Main Case
Disposal Type
Allowed
Last updated 15-Jun-2026
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.STATE OF JAMMU INDUSTRIES AND COMMERCE DEPTT. CIVIL SECRETARIAT COMMISSIONER
Adv. M. SHOEB ALAM (Dead / Retired / Elevated) M. SHOEB ALAM (Dead / Retired / Elevated) [P-2] SUNIL FERNANDES (Dead / Retired / Elevated)
Respondent(s)
-
1.M/S.JAMMU STEEL INDUSTRIES .
Adv. M. P. DEVANATH
Case History
-
Case disposedDisposed
-
18-Aug-2017
Fixed Date by Court
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Navin Sinha
-
09-Aug-2017
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
11-Mar-2016
ROPView PDF
-
11-Mar-2016
ROPView PDF
-
14-Dec-2015
ROPView PDF
-
14-Dec-2015
ROPView PDF
-
17-Sep-2015
ROPView PDF
-
17-Sep-2015
ROPView PDF
-
04-Aug-2015
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
04-Aug-2015
Office Report - of Main CaseView PDF
-
04-Aug-2015
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
13-Apr-2015
ROPView PDF
-
13-Apr-2015
ROPView PDF
-
07-Jan-2015
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
07-Jan-2015
Office Report - of Main CaseView PDF
-
07-Jan-2015
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
27-Oct-2014
ROPView PDF
-
05-Sep-2014
ROPView PDF
-
05-Sep-2014
ROPView PDF
-
21-Jul-2014
ROPView PDF
-
28-Apr-2014
ROPView PDF
-
10-Mar-2014
ROPView PDF
-
07-Feb-2014
ROPView PDF
-
15-Jan-2014
ROPView PDF
-
23-Oct-2013
ROPView PDF
-
10-Sep-2013
ROPView PDF
-
30-Jul-2013
ROPView PDF
-
09-Apr-2013
ROPView PDF
-
29-Oct-2012
ROPView PDF
-
18-Jul-2012
ROPView PDF
-
25-Jan-2012
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
14-Nov-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
10-Oct-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
01-Aug-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
05-Jul-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
28-Mar-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
28-Feb-2011
ROPView PDF
-
24-Jan-2011
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
10-Dec-2010
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
10-Nov-2010
ROPView PDF
-
09-Jul-2010
ROPView PDF
-
23-Apr-2010
ROPView PDF
-
23-Mar-2010
ROPView PDF
-
22-Feb-2010
ROPView PDF
-
12-Jan-2010
ROPView PDF
-
30-Nov-2009
ROPView PDF
-
17-Aug-2009
ROPView PDF
-
20-Mar-2009
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
11-Feb-2009
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
13-Jan-2009
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
04-Dec-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
03-Nov-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
01-Oct-2008
ROPView PDF
-
10-Sep-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
05-Aug-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
16-May-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
04-Apr-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
14-Feb-2008
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
10-Oct-2007
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
17-Jul-2007
ROPView PDF
-
30-Mar-2007
ROPView PDF
-
09-Feb-2007
ROPView PDF
-
18-Aug-2006
ROPView PDF
-
19-Jul-2006
ROPView PDF
-
24-Apr-2006
ROP - of Main CaseView PDF
-
03-Apr-2006
ROPView PDF
-
04-Jan-2006
Case filed
Registration No. C.A. No. 9848/2011
Common Record of Proceedings — heard with connected matters
Lead case: C.A. No. 9844/2011
Case Summary: State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Trikuta Roller Flour Mills Pvt. Ltd. Outcome: The Supreme Court allowed the State's appeals, setting aside the High Court's order. The Court upheld the State's 1993 policy that capped CST refunds for SSI units at Rs. 2 lacs per annum, rejecting the respondents' claims for full refunds over five years. However, the Court clarified that already-granted refunds cannot be withdrawn or reopened. Key Holding: The Court held that CST refunds are executive policy concessions—not legal rights—and can be modified for valid public interest reasons, including preventing fraudulent claims and protecting State finances. Economic policy decisions warrant judicial restraint unless proven arbitrary or unreasonable. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts