PARVATI DEVI vs THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT THROUGH ITS SECRETARY — C.A. No. 4973/2011
Case under Section III-A. Status: DISPOSED.
CNR: SCIN010260982008
Filing Date
08-Sep-2008
Registration No
C.A. No. 4973/2011
Diary Number
26098/2008
Order Date
22-Feb-2023
Document Type
ROP - of Main Case
Disposal Type
Disposed Off
Data as of 03-Jul-2026
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
PARVATI DEVI
Adv. SHAKIL AHMAD SYED[P-1] SHAKIL AHMED SYED (Dead / Retired / Elevated) [P-1]
Respondent(s)
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
Adv. GARIMA PRASHAD (Dead / Retired / Elevated) [R-1] GARIMA PRASHAD (Dead / Retired / Elevated) [R-2] GARIMA PRASHAD (Dead / Retired / Elevated) [R-3] KRISHNANAND PANDEYA[R-1] KRISHNANAND PANDEYA[R-2] KRISHNANAND PANDEYA[R-3] KRISHNANAND PANDEYA[R-4] RAKESH UTTAMCHANDRA UPADHYAY[R-5]
Hearing History
Judge: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ABHAY S. OKA and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH BINDAL
Ordinary
Ordinary
Ordinary
Fixed Date by Court
Fixed Date by Court
| Date | Purpose |
|---|---|
| 22-Feb-2023 | Ordinary |
| 18-Oct-2022 | Ordinary |
| 18-Oct-2022 | Ordinary |
| 19-Sep-2018 | Fixed Date by Court |
| 14-Dec-2017 | Fixed Date by Court |
Orders
Case Summary: Parvati Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh (C.A. No. 4973/2011) The Supreme Court dismissed Parvati Devi's appeal challenging her non-selection for the Siksha Mitras recruitment in 2005. Although Devi scored 52.63%, the selected candidate (Respondent No. 5) scored higher at 53.33%. The Court held that given the passage of time (decision in 2023) and the respondent's superior marks, interference with the 2005 selection was unjust and inappropriate. The Shiksha Mitras scheme was abolished in 2011, and the State had already taken remedial steps via a 2008 Government Order. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Browse Related Cases
Explore other courts