gaya prasad dubey and 1 other vs pariyojana nideshak and 1 other — 376/2022
Case under Arbitration Act Section 34. Disposed: Contested--DISPOSED on 10th April 2026.
Misc. Civil Cases
CNR: UPST010092162022
Filing Number
816/2022
Filing Date
12-Dec-2022
Registration No
376/2022
Registration Date
16-Dec-2022
Court
District and Session Judge
Judge
2-ADJ 1
Decision Date
10-Apr-2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--DISPOSED
Last updated 28-May-2026
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.gaya prasad dubey and 1 other
Adv. Neeraj Kumar Upadhyaya
-
2.rajmani dubey
Respondent(s)
-
1.pariyojana nideshak and 1 other
-
2.arbitrator / DM
Case History
-
Case disposedDisposed
-
10-Apr-2026
JudgementView PDF
Case Summary: 376/2022 Court Decision: The court set aside the arbitration award dated 29-07-2021 passed by the District Magistrate/Arbitrator in a land acquisition dispute under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The arbitrator mechanically passed the award without applying judicial reasoning, ignored available evidence and proper statutory procedures, and failed to consider the compensation based on land market value as required by compensation law. Key Reasoning: The court found the arbitration process deficient as it did not follow the mandated legal methodology, particularly regarding assessment of acquired land value under the National Highways Act and Stamp Act rules. Recent Supreme Court precedents established that Section 34 petitions are time-barred after three months from award receipt, making timeliness a preliminary jurisdictional question. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
-
10-Apr-2026
Disposed
ADJ 1
-
31-Mar-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
13-Mar-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Mar-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
11-Mar-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
10-Mar-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
28-Feb-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-Jan-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
15-Jan-2026
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
10-Dec-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
09-Dec-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
06-Dec-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
25-Nov-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
20-Nov-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
27-Oct-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-Oct-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
10-Oct-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Oct-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
29-Sep-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
22-Sep-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
15-Sep-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
06-Sep-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
26-Aug-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
14-Aug-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Aug-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
01-Aug-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
23-Jul-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-Jul-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
10-Jul-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
08-Jul-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
27-May-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-May-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
07-May-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
30-Apr-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
22-Apr-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
09-Apr-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
02-Apr-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
19-Mar-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
03-Mar-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
14-Feb-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
28-Jan-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
10-Jan-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Jan-2025
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
13-Dec-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
30-Nov-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
15-Nov-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
19-Oct-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
18-Oct-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Sep-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
02-Sep-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
06-Jul-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
28-May-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
03-May-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Apr-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
27-Mar-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Mar-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
27-Feb-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
01-Feb-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
06-Jan-2024
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
14-Dec-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
02-Dec-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
24-Nov-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
02-Nov-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
23-Oct-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Oct-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Oct-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
26-Sep-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Sep-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
05-Sep-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
24-Aug-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-Aug-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Aug-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
20-Jul-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
12-Jul-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
07-Jul-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
31-May-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
17-May-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
09-May-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-May-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
25-Apr-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
11-Apr-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Apr-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
14-Mar-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
27-Feb-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
16-Feb-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
02-Feb-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
17-Jan-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
04-Jan-2023
Hearing
ADJ 1
-
23-Dec-2022
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
12-Dec-2022
Case filed
Registration No. 376/2022
Case Summary: 376/2022 Court Decision: The court set aside the arbitration award dated 29-07-2021 passed by the District Magistrate/Arbitrator in a land acquisition dispute under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The arbitrator mechanically passed the award without applying judicial reasoning, ignored available evidence and proper statutory procedures, and failed to consider the compensation based on land market value as required by compensation law. Key Reasoning: The court found the arbitration process deficient as it did not follow the mandated legal methodology, particularly regarding assessment of acquired land value under the National Highways Act and Stamp Act rules. Recent Supreme Court precedents established that Section 34 petitions are time-barred after three months from award receipt, making timeliness a preliminary jurisdictional question. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts