AYYASAMY vs KANNIMARIYAL Advocate - P Sankar kumar — 1/2024

Disposed

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Judgement

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Arguments

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Arguments

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Copy of Oral Evidence/DepositionView PDF

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Part Heard

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Copy of Oral Evidence/DepositionView PDF

Summary of Case 1/2024 - Ayyasamy v. Kannimariyal The court examined the testimony of a property valuator (Prabakar) regarding his valuation report (Exhibit 5) of a property in Thava on 23.03.2023. During cross-examination, the valuator admitted significant deficiencies in his assessment: he lacked proper government licensure credentials, did not examine soil bearing capacity for foundation design, failed to conduct a detailed technical analysis of construction methods, and did not provide itemized costs of materials and labor. Critically, he performed the valuation unilaterally at the plaintiff's request without the defendant's presence or knowledge, relying solely on blueprints rather than comprehensive site inspection, and did not disclose approximately ₹10 lakh worth of remaining construction materials. The court found the valuator's report legally deficient and incapable of binding the defendant, as it lacked objectivity and technical rigor required for such expert assessments. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Copy of Oral Evidence/DepositionView PDF

Copy of Oral Evidence/DepositionView PDF

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Copy of Oral Evidence/DepositionView PDF

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Evidence

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

For further Proceedings

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Trial

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Trial

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Issues

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

For further Proceedings

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Written Statement

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Written Statement

Sub Court,Rajapalayam

Issue of Service

First hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Case filed

Registration No. 1/2024