Gajanan Shankar Tambutkar and ors vs M/s. S.D.O. Land Acquisition Mahad Division and ors — 66/2020

Case under Land Acquisition Act Section 28 A (3). Disposed: Contested--PARTLY ALLOWED on 02nd May 2026.

L.A.R. - Land Ref.

CNR: MHRG190010372023

Case disposed

Filing Number

66/2020

Filing Date

07-12-2020

Registration No

66/2020

Registration Date

08-12-2020

Court

Court of Civil Judge S.D. Mahad

Judge

1-Civil Judge Senior Division, Mahad

Decision Date

02nd May 2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--PARTLY ALLOWED

Acts & Sections

Land Acquisition Act Section 28 A (3)

Petitioner(s)

Gajanan Shankar Tambutkar and ors

Adv. Navale B. T.

Dipak Shankar Tambutkar

Asmita Anil Kirdavkar

Isha @ Ratnaprabha Viswas Sutar

Usha Dhondu Nigadekar

Manish Ganesh Sutar

Shanta Suresh Walavankar

Ankush Raman Tamhankar

Respondent(s)

M/s. S.D.O. Land Acquisition Mahad Division and ors

M/s Collector Alibag - Raigad

Exe. Engineer Hetawane Kalawa division

Hearing History

Judge: 1-Civil Judge Senior Division, Mahad

02-05-2026

Disposed

08-04-2026

Arguments

02-04-2026

Arguments

23-03-2026

Arguments

12-03-2026

Evidence

Final Orders / Judgements

02-05-2026
Copy of Judgment

Case Summary: LAR No. 66/2020 Court Decision The Civil Judge, Senior Division, Mahad partly allowed the reference and enhanced land compensation from the original award amount to Rs. 700/- per sq. meter for agricultural land acquired at Karanjadi village. The court found the original compensation inadequate and not reflective of prevailing market value, while rejecting the applicants' claim for Rs. 1,000/- per sq. meter as excessive. Key Reasoning The court held that the Special Land Acquisition Officer erred by: (1) grouping lands based on outdated revenue assessment rather than actual market conditions; (2) relying solely on government "ready reckoner" rates; and (3) ignoring comparable sale transactions and the land's non-agricultural development potential near M.I.D.C. Mahad. The court applied a 65% deduction for development costs from comparable sales, arriving at Rs. 700/- per sq. meter as fair market value. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Interim Orders

casestatus.in Summary

Case Summary: LAR No. 66/2020 Court Decision The Civil Judge, Senior Division, Mahad partly allowed the reference and enhanced land compensation from the original award amount to Rs. 700/- per sq. meter for agricultural land acquired at Karanjadi village. The court found the original compensation inadequate and not reflective of prevailing market value, while rejecting the applicants' claim for Rs. 1,000/- per sq. meter as excessive. Key Reasoning The court held that the Special Land Acquisition Officer erred by: (1) grouping lands based on outdated revenue assessment rather than actual market conditions; (2) relying solely on government "ready reckoner" rates; and (3) ignoring comparable sale transactions and the land's non-agricultural development potential near M.I.D.C. Mahad. The court applied a 65% deduction for development costs from comparable sales, arriving at Rs. 700/- per sq. meter as fair market value. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Browse Related Cases

Cases under same legislation

More from this court

Court of Civil Judge S.D. Mahad All courts →

Explore other courts

Search Another Case