Sushilabai Gurulingayya Swami vs 1. The Project Director, National Highway Authority of India Advocate - Shaikh Jahangir B. — 41/2022

Case under Arbitration and Conciliation Act Section 34. Disposed: Contested--DECREED on 07th May 2026.

Case disposed

Civil M.A. - Civil Misc. Application

CNR: MHOS050004132022

Filing Number

279/2022

Filing Date

27-Jun-2022

Registration No

41/2022

Registration Date

27-Jun-2022

Court

Additional District Judge , Omerga

Judge

1-District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

Decision Date

07-May-2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--DECREED

Last updated 23-Jun-2026

Acts & Sections

Arbitration and Conciliation Act Section 34

Petitioner(s)

  1. 1.Sushilabai Gurulingayya Swami

    Adv. Birajdar Parmeshwar S.

Respondent(s)

  1. 1.1. The Project Director, National Highway Authority of India Advocate - Shaikh Jahangir B.

  2. 2.2. The Competent Authority and Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition (Manjara Project)

Case History

  1. Case disposedDisposed

  2. 07-May-2026

    Copy of Judgment

    Case Summary: Sushilabai Gurulingayya Swami v. NHAI (41/2022) The District Court set aside an arbitrator's award of Rs.333/sq.m compensation for land acquired by NHAI, finding patent illegality under Section 34(2-A) of the Arbitration Act. The court determined the arbitrator failed to independently assess compensation as required under the National Highways Act and ignored comparable awards to nearby similar properties (Rs.810-900/sq.m), violating the principle of parity for lands acquired for the same highway project. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

  3. 07-May-2026

    Disposed

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  4. 27-Apr-2026

    Judgment

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  5. 04-Apr-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  6. 23-Mar-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  7. 18-Mar-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  8. 07-Mar-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  9. 16-Feb-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  10. 31-Jan-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  11. 16-Jan-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  12. 03-Jan-2026

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  13. 18-Dec-2025

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  14. 12-Dec-2025

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  15. 08-Dec-2025

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  16. 28-Nov-2025

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  17. 13-Nov-2025

    Steps

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  18. 18-Oct-2025

    Order on Exhibit

  19. 18-Oct-2025

    Steps

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  20. 14-Aug-2025

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Adhoc District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge

  21. 18-Jun-2025

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Adhoc District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge

  22. 17-Mar-2025

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Extra Jt. Adhoc District and Sessions Judge, Omerga

  23. 06-Mar-2025

    Judgment

    Extra Jt. Adhoc District and Sessions Judge, Omerga

  24. 21-Feb-2025

    Judgment

    Extra Jt. Adhoc District and Sessions Judge, Omerga

  25. 24-Jan-2025

    Arguments

    Extra Jt. Adhoc District and Sessions Judge, Omerga

  26. 04-Nov-2024

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  27. 09-Jul-2024

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  28. 19-Apr-2024

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  29. 02-Apr-2024

    Arguments

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  30. 21-Nov-2023

    Hearing

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  31. 21-Aug-2023

    Hearing

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  32. 30-Apr-2023

    Lok-Nyayalaya

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  33. 10-Apr-2023

    Lok-Nyayalaya

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  34. 17-Jan-2023

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  35. 07-Oct-2022

    W.S. and Say

    District Judge-1 and Addl. Sessions Judge Omerga.

  36. 27-Jun-2022

    First hearing

    Initial hearing scheduled

  37. 27-Jun-2022

    Case filed

    Registration No. 41/2022

casestatus.in Summary

Case Summary: Sushilabai Gurulingayya Swami v. NHAI (41/2022) The District Court set aside an arbitrator's award of Rs.333/sq.m compensation for land acquired by NHAI, finding patent illegality under Section 34(2-A) of the Arbitration Act. The court determined the arbitrator failed to independently assess compensation as required under the National Highways Act and ignored comparable awards to nearby similar properties (Rs.810-900/sq.m), violating the principle of parity for lands acquired for the same highway project. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Explore other courts

High Courts Supreme Court
Search Another Case