Shri. Babu Dattu Hirugade vs Shri. Anil Yashavant Kulkarni Advocate - G. T. Khot — 1700158/2003

Case under Code of Civil Procedure Section SuitforPermanentInJunction. Status: Evidence. Next hearing: 09th October 2026.

Evidence Next hearing 09-Oct-2026 in 4 weeks

R.C.S. - Regular Civil Suit

CNR: MHKO130003732003

Filing Number

1700158/2003

Filing Date

20-Dec-2003

Registration No

1700158/2003

Registration Date

20-Dec-2003

Court

Civil and Criminal Court , Kagal

Judge

10-Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

Last updated 06-Sep-2026

Acts & Sections

Code of Civil Procedure Section SuitforPermanentInJunction

Petitioner(s)

  1. 1.Shri. Babu Dattu Hirugade

    Adv. S. S. Kestikar

  2. 2.Dnyanu @ Janu Aba Tambekar.

  3. 3.Shankar Aba Hirugade.

  4. 4.Shivaji Dattu Hirugade.

  5. 5.Vilas Dattu Hirugade.

  6. 6.Vithu Aba Tambekar.

  7. 7.Appaso Aba Tambekar.

Respondent(s)

  1. 1.Shri. Anil Yashavant Kulkarni Advocate - G. T. Khot

  2. 2.Arun Yashwant Kulkarni.

  3. 3.Rekha Suresh Minchekar.

  4. 4.Sou.Priyawanda Arun Patwardhan.

  5. 5.Maruti Shamrao Mhatugade.

Case History

  1. 09-Oct-2026

    Next hearingPending

  2. 31-Aug-2026

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  3. 10-Aug-2026

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  4. 18-Jul-2026

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  5. 02-Jul-2026

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  6. 19-Jun-2026

    Order on ExhibitView PDF

  7. 19-Jun-2026

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  8. 30-Apr-2026

    Hearing

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  9. 18-Apr-2026

    Hearing

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  10. 10-Apr-2026

    Hearing

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  11. 30-Mar-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  12. 20-Mar-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  13. 02-Mar-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  14. 21-Feb-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  15. 16-Feb-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  16. 05-Feb-2026

    Order on ExhibitView PDF

  17. 05-Feb-2026

    Dismissal Order

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  18. 20-Jan-2026

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  19. 17-Dec-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  20. 01-Dec-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  21. 17-Nov-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  22. 27-Oct-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  23. 24-Sep-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  24. 14-Aug-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  25. 25-Jun-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  26. 21-Apr-2025

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  27. 24-Mar-2025

    Steps

  28. 12-Mar-2025

    Steps

  29. 17-Feb-2025

    Steps

  30. 20-Jan-2025

    Steps

  31. 21-Dec-2024

    Steps

  32. 11-Nov-2024

    Steps

  33. 20-Sep-2024

    Steps

  34. 06-Sep-2024

    Steps

  35. 26-Jul-2024

    Steps

  36. 13-Jun-2024

    Steps

  37. 24-Apr-2024

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  38. 06-Mar-2024

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  39. 22-Jan-2024

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  40. 20-Dec-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  41. 13-Dec-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  42. 16-Oct-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  43. 08-Sep-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  44. 26-Jul-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  45. 15-Jun-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  46. 03-Apr-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  47. 17-Mar-2023

    Steps

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  48. 10-Feb-2023

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  49. 05-Jan-2023

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  50. 21-Nov-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  51. 12-Oct-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  52. 14-Sep-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  53. 26-Aug-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  54. 10-Aug-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  55. 30-Jun-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  56. 08-Jun-2022

    Evidence

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  57. 13-Apr-2022

    Evidence

  58. 09-Mar-2022

    Evidence

  59. 29-Jan-2022

    Evidence

  60. 10-Jan-2022

    Evidence

  61. 06-Jan-2022

    Arguments

  62. 09-Dec-2021

    Arguments

  63. 15-Nov-2021

    Arguments

  64. 30-Oct-2021

    Arguments

  65. 07-Oct-2021

    Arguments

  66. 15-Sep-2021

    Arguments

  67. 07-Aug-2021

    Arguments

  68. 27-Jul-2021

    Arguments

  69. 05-May-2021

    Arguments

  70. 30-Mar-2021

    Arguments

  71. 18-Mar-2021

    Arguments

  72. 10-Feb-2021

    Arguments

  73. 15-Jan-2021

    Arguments

  74. 04-Jan-2021

    Arguments

  75. 15-Dec-2020

    Arguments

  76. 01-Dec-2020

    Arguments

  77. 12-Nov-2020

    Arguments

  78. 02-Nov-2020

    Arguments

  79. 23-Oct-2020

    Arguments

  80. 27-Aug-2020

    Arguments

  81. 03-Aug-2020

    Arguments

  82. 24-Jul-2020

    Arguments

  83. 24-Jun-2020

    Arguments

  84. 26-May-2020

    Arguments

  85. 05-May-2020

    Arguments

  86. 16-Apr-2020

    Arguments

  87. 20-Mar-2020

    Arguments

  88. 29-Feb-2020

    Arguments

  89. 14-Feb-2020

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  90. 18-Jan-2020

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  91. 20-Dec-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  92. 16-Nov-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  93. 02-Nov-2019

    Order on ExhibitView PDF

  94. 02-Nov-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  95. 19-Oct-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  96. 09-Oct-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  97. 20-Sep-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  98. 16-Sep-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  99. 09-Sep-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  100. 26-Aug-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  101. 14-Aug-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  102. 01-Aug-2019

    Order on ExhibitView PDF

  103. 01-Aug-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  104. 09-Jul-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  105. 03-Jul-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  106. 27-Jun-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  107. 07-Jun-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  108. 15-Mar-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  109. 26-Feb-2019

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  110. 11-Feb-2019

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  111. 24-Jan-2019

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  112. 04-Jan-2019

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  113. 28-Nov-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  114. 01-Nov-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  115. 26-Sep-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  116. 24-Aug-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  117. 20-Jul-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  118. 20-Jun-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  119. 27-Apr-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  120. 13-Apr-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  121. 19-Mar-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  122. 07-Mar-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  123. 03-Mar-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  124. 15-Feb-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  125. 01-Feb-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  126. 20-Jan-2018

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  127. 21-Dec-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  128. 30-Nov-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  129. 13-Nov-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  130. 11-Oct-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  131. 18-Sep-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  132. 07-Sep-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  133. 24-Aug-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  134. 11-Aug-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  135. 27-Jul-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  136. 05-Jul-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  137. 12-Jun-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  138. 02-May-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  139. 21-Mar-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  140. 27-Feb-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  141. 16-Feb-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  142. 03-Feb-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  143. 12-Jan-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  144. 05-Jan-2017

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  145. 22-Dec-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  146. 01-Dec-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  147. 03-Nov-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  148. 05-Oct-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  149. 23-Sep-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  150. 07-Sep-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  151. 10-Aug-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  152. 24-Jun-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  153. 02-Apr-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  154. 08-Mar-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  155. 28-Jan-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  156. 04-Jan-2016

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  157. 27-Nov-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  158. 09-Oct-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  159. 26-Aug-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  160. 31-Jul-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  161. 17-Jun-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  162. 21-Apr-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  163. 27-Mar-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  164. 27-Feb-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  165. 20-Jan-2015

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  166. 20-Dec-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  167. 06-Dec-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  168. 08-Nov-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

  169. 28-Oct-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  170. 08-Oct-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  171. 26-Sep-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  172. 22-Aug-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  173. 24-Jul-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  174. 01-Jul-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  175. 17-Jun-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  176. 22-Apr-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  177. 21-Mar-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  178. 11-Mar-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  179. 07-Mar-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  180. 14-Feb-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  181. 29-Jan-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  182. 08-Jan-2014

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  183. 04-Dec-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  184. 19-Nov-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  185. 29-Oct-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  186. 25-Oct-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  187. 23-Oct-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  188. 30-Sep-2013

    Argument on Exh.____Unready

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  189. 03-Sep-2013

    Order on Exh

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  190. 13-Aug-2013

    Order on Exh

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  191. 01-Aug-2013

    Order on Exh

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  192. 15-Jul-2013

    Order on Exh

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  193. 21-Jun-2013

    Order on Exh

    Jt. C.J.J.D. J.M.F.C.Kagal.-2

  194. 03-May-2013

    Order on Exh

  195. 09-Apr-2013

    Order on Exh

  196. 07-Mar-2013

    Order on Exh

  197. 28-Jan-2013

    Order on Exh

  198. 25-Jan-2013

    Order on Exh

  199. 09-Jan-2013

    Order on Exh

  200. 07-Nov-2012

    Order on Exh

  201. 01-Oct-2012

    Order on Exh

  202. 24-Aug-2012

    Order on Exh

  203. 04-Aug-2012

    Order on Exh

  204. 25-Jul-2012

    Order on Exh

  205. 04-Jul-2012

    Order on Exh

  206. 13-Jun-2012

    Order on Exh

  207. 05-May-2012

    Order on Exh

  208. 27-Apr-2012

    Order on Exh

  209. 27-Mar-2012

    Order on Exh

  210. 20-Mar-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  211. 09-Mar-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  212. 28-Feb-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  213. 15-Feb-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  214. 07-Feb-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  215. 03-Feb-2012

    Filing of Say on Exh___Unready

  216. 25-Jan-2012

    W.S. and Say

  217. 13-Jan-2012

    W.S. and Say

  218. 23-Dec-2011

    W.S. and Say

  219. 20-Dec-2011

    W.S. and Say

  220. 15-Nov-2011

    W.S. and Say

  221. 01-Nov-2011

    W.S. and Say

  222. 18-Oct-2011

    W.S. and Say

  223. 11-Oct-2011

    W.S. and Say

  224. 27-Sep-2011

    W.S. and Say

  225. 22-Sep-2011

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  226. 17-Sep-2011

    Order on Exh

  227. 13-Sep-2011

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  228. 03-Sep-2011

    W.S. and Say

  229. 30-Aug-2011

    Amended Plaint

  230. 25-Aug-2011

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  231. 24-Aug-2011

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  232. 10-Aug-2011

    W.S. and Say

  233. 30-Jul-2011

    W.S. and Say

  234. 15-Jul-2011

    Hearing

  235. 04-Jul-2011

    Hearing

  236. 16-Jun-2011

    Hearing

  237. 08-Jun-2011

    Hearing

  238. 20-Apr-2011

    Hearing

  239. 18-Mar-2011

    Hearing

  240. 09-Feb-2011

    Hearing

  241. 03-Jan-2011

    Hearing

  242. 04-Dec-2010

    Hearing

  243. 18-Nov-2010

    Hearing

  244. 13-Oct-2010

    Hearing

  245. 15-Sep-2010

    Hearing

  246. 01-Sep-2010

    Hearing

  247. 13-Aug-2010

    Hearing

  248. 21-Jul-2010

    Dismissal Order

  249. 05-Jul-2010

    Amended Plaint

  250. 08-Jun-2010

    Amended Plaint

  251. 30-Apr-2010

    Amended Plaint

  252. 06-Apr-2010

    Amended Plaint

  253. 09-Mar-2010

    Amended Plaint

  254. 22-Feb-2010

    Amended Plaint

  255. 27-Jan-2010

    W.S. and Say

  256. 04-Jan-2010

    W.S. and Say

  257. 02-Dec-2009

    W.S. and Say

  258. 30-Nov-2009

    W.S. and Say

  259. 09-Nov-2009

    W.S. and Say

  260. 02-Nov-2009

    W.S. and Say

  261. 28-Oct-2009

    W.S. and Say

  262. 24-Sep-2009

    W.S. and Say

  263. 09-Sep-2009

    W.S. and Say

  264. 20-Aug-2009

    W.S. and Say

  265. 04-Aug-2009

    Hearing

  266. 07-Jul-2009

    Hearing

  267. 17-Jun-2009

    Hearing

  268. 18-Mar-2009

    Hearing

  269. 13-Jan-2009

    Hearing

  270. 08-Dec-2008

    Hearing

  271. 04-Nov-2008

    Hearing

  272. 16-Sep-2008

    Hearing

  273. 11-Aug-2008

    Hearing

  274. 19-Jun-2008

    Hearing

  275. 22-Apr-2008

    Hearing

  276. 14-Mar-2008

    Hearing

  277. 20-Feb-2008

    Hearing

  278. 28-Jan-2008

    Hearing

  279. 10-Dec-2007

    Hearing

  280. 14-Nov-2007

    Hearing

  281. 20-Oct-2007

    Hearing

  282. 14-Oct-2007

    Hearing

  283. 10-Oct-2007

    Hearing

  284. 12-Sep-2007

    Hearing

  285. 09-Aug-2007

    Issues

  286. 19-Jul-2007

    Issues

  287. 17-Apr-2007

    Issues

  288. 17-Mar-2007

    Issues

  289. 28-Feb-2007

    Issues

  290. 18-Dec-2006

    Steps_Unready

  291. 18-Oct-2006

    Issues

  292. 22-Aug-2006

    Issues

  293. 13-Jul-2006

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  294. 17-May-2006

    Say / Hearing on Exh____Ready

  295. 29-Apr-2006

    Hearing

  296. 25-Apr-2006

    Hearing

  297. 10-Apr-2006

    Hearing

  298. 28-Mar-2006

    Hearing

  299. 23-Mar-2006

    Order on Exh

  300. 04-Mar-2006

    Order on Exh

  301. 15-Feb-2006

    Order on Exh

  302. 04-Feb-2006

    Order on Exh

  303. 14-Dec-2005

    First hearing

    Initial hearing scheduled

  304. 20-Dec-2003

    Case filed

    Registration No. 1700158/2003

Explore other courts

Search Another Case