Aleena Andrew,Wo.Andrew vs Antony Davis Advocate - K.GOPINADHAN — 200137/2015

JudgementView PDF

Case Summary: OS 137/2015 Court Decision: The court issued a preliminary decree for partition of inherited properties among five siblings, but rejected the plaintiffs' claims for complete equal shares. The court found that the deceased mother (Lilly Keettickal) validly assigned portions of her share to the first defendant before her death, despite evidence of her mental illness history. Key Reasoning: While the plaintiffs proved Lilly suffered from schizophrenia for 40 years, the court held that mere mental illness history is insufficient to void transactions. Evidence showed Lilly independently managed finances, executed registered documents, and actively participated in property transfers between 2011-2012, demonstrating sound disposing capacity at the time of execution. However, one gift deed (Exhibit B20) was deemed void for lacking required witness signatures. Outcome: Most plaint properties were declared partible with shares divided equally among the five heirs (1/5 each), except portions validly assigned by Lilly to the first defendant are excluded from partition. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Disposed

Principal Sub Judge

Order/ Judgement

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

Order/Judgement

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

No sitting notified

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For production of documents/Affidavit

Principal Sub Judge

For Steps

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For hearing on IA

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Counter

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Counter

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

For Steps

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

For production of documents/Affidavit

Principal Sub Judge

For production of documents/Affidavit

Principal Sub Judge

For production of documents/Affidavit

Principal Sub Judge

For Counter

Principal Sub Judge

For Counter

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

Repeat Summons

Principal Sub Judge

Repeat Summons

Principal Sub Judge

Call on

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

For reports

Principal Sub Judge

Call on

Principal Sub Judge

For Depositting Batta

Principal Sub Judge

Judge on leave / duty

Principal Sub Judge

Adjourned

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

Call on

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

Issue Summons

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

Issue notice

Principal Sub Judge

For Hearing

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

Call on

Principal Sub Judge

Issue Summons

Principal Sub Judge

Call with IA

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For Steps

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

For commission report

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Referred to Mediator

Principal Sub Judge

Listed to

Principal Sub Judge

Listed to

Principal Sub Judge

Listed to

Principal Sub Judge

Listed to

Principal Sub Judge

Listed to

Principal Sub Judge

Adjourned

Principal Sub Judge

No sitting notified

Principal Sub Judge

No sitting notified

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Objection

Principal Sub Judge

For reports

Principal Sub Judge

For Objection and hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Objection and hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Objection and hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Objection and hearing

Principal Sub Judge

For Objection and hearing

Principal Sub Judge

Adjourned

Principal Sub Judge

No sitting notified

Principal Sub Judge

Verify and report

Principal Sub Judge

Written Statement

Principal Sub Judge

Restored

Principal Sub Judge

Call on

Principal Sub Judge

Disposed

Principal Sub Judge

Disposed

Principal Sub Judge

For evidence

Principal Sub Judge

For evidence

Principal Sub Judge

For evidence

Principal Sub Judge

For evidence

Principal Sub Judge

For evidence

Principal Sub Judge

Payment of balance court fee.

Principal Sub Judge

for evidence.

Principal Sub Judge

Judge on leave / duty

Principal Sub Judge

Judge on leave / duty

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Await report

Principal Sub Judge

Written Statement

Principal Sub Judge

Written Statement

Principal Sub Judge

First hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Case filed

Registration No. 200137/2015