Shubha vs Jonson Advocate - APPUKUTTAN K K — 309/2025

Case Summary: Shubha v. Johnson (OS 309/2025) Outcome: Interlocutory Application dismissed without costs. Shubha sought a permanent prohibitory injunction to restrain Johnson from continuing illegal construction of a three-storied building on his adjacent property in Vadakkencherry. The Munsiff court rejected her request, finding she failed to establish a prima facie case: the commissioner's report showed she owned no property directly adjoining the disputed construction site, making the alleged harm indirect. The court also found the vague commissioner report lacked crucial details about measurements and distance violations. Additionally, construction was already substantially completed, and balance of convenience favored refusing injunction to avoid considerable loss to the respondent. The petitioner was directed to pursue remedies under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act instead. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.