Joseph Martin Dsouza vs Epipaniya Disouza — 42/2019
Case under Under Order 41 Rule 1 and 2 of Cpc 1908. Status: Await Order. Next hearing: 12th June 2026.
R.A. - Regular Appeals
CNR: KAUK320003282019
Filing Number
40/2019
Filing Date
22-Nov-2019
Registration No
42/2019
Registration Date
22-Nov-2019
Court
SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, BHATKAL
Judge
1229-Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
Last updated 05-Jun-2026
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.Joseph Martin Dsouza
Adv. K. R. Naik
Respondent(s)
-
1.Epipaniya Disouza
-
2.Latish W/o Suresh Naik
-
3.Smt. Juliyana Kom Duming Dsouza
-
4.James Dsouza
-
5.Bernad Dsouza
-
6.Tony Dsouza
-
7.Anita Dsouza
-
8.Marry Dsouza
-
9.Veena Dsouza
-
10.Noyal
-
11.Glan Dias
-
12.Teresa Dsouza
-
13.Isaparance Dsouza
-
14.Mark S/o Pelis Dsouza
-
15.Eliza S/o Bastav Dsouza
-
16.Francis S/o Bastav Dsouza
-
17.Shankar Narayan Bhatrabhitlu
Case History
-
12-Jun-2026
Next hearingPending
-
17-Apr-2026
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Mar-2026
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Feb-2026
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
09-Jan-2026
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Nov-2025
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Oct-2025
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
26-Sep-2025
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
29-Aug-2025
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
25-Jul-2025
Await Order
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
04-Jul-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Jun-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
25-Apr-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
04-Apr-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
14-Mar-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Feb-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
31-Jan-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
10-Jan-2025
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Dec-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Nov-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-Nov-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
29-Oct-2024
OrdersView PDF
Case Summary: 42/2019 Outcome: The Interlocutory Application (IA No. III) filed by appellant Joseph Martin D'Soza seeking permission to produce additional evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC has been DISMISSED by the Senior Civil Judge, Bhatkal on 29 October 2024. Key Finding: The court found that the appellant failed to establish sufficient grounds for admitting additional evidence. The appellant admitted obtaining documents from the Land Tribunal only after the trial court's dismissal, but could not prove these documents were unknown to him despite exercising due diligence during the original trial. Since the documents were publicly available and the appellant provided no valid reason for their earlier non-production, the application was rejected. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
-
29-Oct-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
19-Oct-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
16-Oct-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
30-Sep-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
09-Sep-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Aug-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
29-Jul-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
05-Jul-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Jun-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
31-May-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
19-Apr-2024
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
05-Apr-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Mar-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
15-Mar-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
01-Mar-2024
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
16-Feb-2024
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
02-Feb-2024
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
12-Jan-2024
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
05-Jan-2024
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
15-Dec-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-Dec-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Nov-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
10-Nov-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
27-Oct-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
06-Oct-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Sep-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-Sep-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
04-Sep-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
31-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
29-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
26-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
14-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
11-Aug-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Jul-2023
Orders
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
30-Jun-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
09-Jun-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
02-Jun-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Apr-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Mar-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Mar-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Feb-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
10-Feb-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
20-Jan-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Jan-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
06-Jan-2023
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
16-Dec-2022
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
09-Dec-2022
Objection to IA
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
02-Dec-2022
Hearing On I A
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
18-Nov-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Oct-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
30-Sep-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
09-Sep-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
02-Sep-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
12-Aug-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Jul-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
01-Jul-2022
Hearing
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Jun-2022
Hearing
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
03-Jun-2022
Objection to IA
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-Apr-2022
Objection to IA
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
25-Mar-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
11-Mar-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
04-Feb-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
07-Jan-2022
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Dec-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
03-Dec-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
19-Nov-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
29-Oct-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-Oct-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Sep-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
27-Aug-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
30-Jul-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
02-Jul-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
28-May-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
26-Mar-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
12-Mar-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
19-Feb-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Jan-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Jan-2021
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
04-Dec-2020
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
16-Oct-2020
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
18-Sep-2020
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
21-Aug-2020
Arguments
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
10-Jul-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
12-Jun-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-May-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
08-May-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Apr-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
27-Mar-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
06-Mar-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
14-Feb-2020
Notice
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
24-Jan-2020
Notice
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
17-Jan-2020
For steps
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
03-Jan-2020
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
13-Dec-2019
Lcr
Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Court, Bhatkal
-
22-Nov-2019
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
22-Nov-2019
Case filed
Registration No. 42/2019
Case Summary: 42/2019 Outcome: The Interlocutory Application (IA No. III) filed by appellant Joseph Martin D'Soza seeking permission to produce additional evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC has been DISMISSED by the Senior Civil Judge, Bhatkal on 29 October 2024. Key Finding: The court found that the appellant failed to establish sufficient grounds for admitting additional evidence. The appellant admitted obtaining documents from the Land Tribunal only after the trial court's dismissal, but could not prove these documents were unknown to him despite exercising due diligence during the original trial. Since the documents were publicly available and the appellant provided no valid reason for their earlier non-production, the application was rejected. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts