Makbul Babajan Maktumiyanavar Age 37 yrs R/o Mahantesh Nagar Tq Savanur Dist Haveri vs Sayyedmeera Abdulkhadar Narayanapur Age 80 yrs R/o Chandani Nagar Tq Savanur Dist Haveri — 405/2025

Summary The compromise petition filed jointly by the plaintiff and defendant on 04-12-2025 is rejected. The court found that while an oral gift (Hiba) under Muslim personal law is valid if certain conditions are met, it cannot override statutory restrictions under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964. The court held that accepting the compromise would indirectly validate the illegal fragmentation of agricultural land into unauthorized plots below the minimum prescribed extent (5 guntas), thereby facilitating unauthorized layouts contrary to public interest and planning regulations. No costs awarded. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.