MAHADEVAPPA S/O KARAVEERAPPA ULLAGADDI vs SRI SHEKHARGOUDA S/O SHIVANAGOUDA HITTALMANI Advocate - SRI.G.C.BADIGER — 332/2024

Orders

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence12

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

OrdersView PDF

Case Summary: O.S. No. 332/2024 The court rejected the defendants' application seeking dismissal of the plaintiff's suit. The plaintiff filed a property dispute suit based on an unregistered sale deed dated June 15, 2017, claiming declaration of title and seeking injunction relief. The defendants argued the suit was unmaintainable because the unregistered sale deed confers no legal rights and is barred under Sections 17 and 49 of the Registration Act, 1908. The court held that while deciding plaint rejection applications, only the plaintiff's pleading averments—not defendant defenses—must be considered. The court found the plaintiff's pleading disclosed a valid cause of action (execution of sale deed, possession delivery, consideration received, and failure to register). Though an unregistered sale deed cannot confer title or prove the main transaction, it can be relied upon for collateral purposes like possession. The admissibility of the document and ultimate success are evidentiary matters for trial, not grounds for plaint rejection. Accordingly, the court rejected the defendants' interim application and allowed the suit to proceed. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Issues

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Orders

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Orders

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Orders

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Written statement

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Amendment

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Amendment

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Amendment

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Amendment

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Amendment

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Objection

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Evidence

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

IssueView PDF

Evidence

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

OrdersView PDF

Issues

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Orders

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Hearing

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Written statement

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Written statement

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

Summons

I Addl Senior CIVIL Judge And JMFC Hubli

First hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Case filed

Registration No. 332/2024