Government of Gujarat vs HASAN @ ASHISH HABIBBHAI MANEK Advocate - J.B.BELIM — 242/2020
Case under Indian Penal Code Section 338,337,504,506(2),114. Disposed: Contested--JUDGMENT BY ACQUITTAL on 13th May 2026.
CC - CRIMINAL CASE
CNR: GJSN020002822020
Filing Number
242/2020
Filing Date
03-Feb-2020
Registration No
242/2020
Registration Date
03-Feb-2020
Court
CIVIL COURT SURENDRANAGAR
Judge
1-Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
Decision Date
13-May-2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--JUDGMENT BY ACQUITTAL
Last updated 16-Jun-2026
FIR Details
FIR Number
120
Police Station
SURENDRANAGAR CITY POLICE STATION - SURENDRANAGAR DISTRICT
Year
2019
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.Government of Gujarat
Adv. APP
Respondent(s)
-
1.HASAN @ ASHISH HABIBBHAI MANEK Advocate - J.B.BELIM
-
2.RAMZANBHAI HABIBBHAI MANEK
Adv. J.B.BELIM
-
3.MARIYAMBEN @ PINKI D/O HABIBBHAI MANEK
Adv. J.B.BELIM
Case History
-
Case disposedDisposed
-
13-May-2026
Judegement
Case Summary: C.C. No. 242/2020 Court's Decision: The accused (Ashish Habibbhai Manek, Ramzanbhai Habibbhai Manek, and Mariyamben) were acquitted of charges under IPC Sections 337, 338, 504, 506(2), and 114. The complainant failed to prove the allegations beyond reasonable doubt, as witness testimonies contained significant contradictions and lacked corroboration with the written complaint and medical evidence regarding injuries sustained on December 17, 2019. Key Reasoning: The court found irreconcilable discrepancies between the complainant's and prosecution witnesses' statements regarding the incident details, timing, and injuries. The prosecution's evidence insufficiently established that the accused had intentionally used threatening words or made death threats with the requisite criminal intent required under Section 506(2) IPC. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
-
13-May-2026
Disposed
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
23-Apr-2026
Judgement
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
30-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
17-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
13-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
28-Feb-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
20-Feb-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
13-Feb-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
05-Feb-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
28-Jan-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
23-Jan-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
19-Jan-2026
Final Arguments
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
16-Jan-2026
Further Statement
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
31-Dec-2025
Further Statement
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
10-Dec-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
29-Nov-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
15-Nov-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
06-Nov-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
18-Oct-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
04-Oct-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
20-Sep-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
30-Aug-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
22-Aug-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
01-Aug-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
11-Jul-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
27-Jun-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
13-Jun-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
26-May-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
01-May-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
05-Apr-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
26-Mar-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
04-Mar-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
04-Feb-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
23-Jan-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
04-Jan-2025
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
06-Dec-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
19-Nov-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
14-Oct-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
25-Sep-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
02-Sep-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
30-Jul-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
08-Jul-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
11-Jun-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
20-May-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
24-Apr-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
03-Apr-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
15-Mar-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
14-Feb-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
20-Jan-2024
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
22-Dec-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
06-Dec-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
04-Nov-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
20-Oct-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
Principal Senior CIVIL Judge
-
29-Sep-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
24-Aug-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
03-Aug-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
18-Jul-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
11-Jul-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
24-May-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
01-May-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
18-Apr-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
23-Mar-2023
Evidence Of Prosecution
2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.
-
28-Dec-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
2Nd Addl CIVIL Judge & JMFC
-
06-Oct-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
2Nd Addl CIVIL Judge & JMFC
-
17-Sep-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
18-Aug-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
13-Jul-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
07-Jun-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
04-Apr-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
21-Jan-2022
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
21-Oct-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
17-Aug-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
08-Jun-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
15-Apr-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
03-Mar-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
02-Mar-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
18-Feb-2021
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
29-Dec-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
16-Oct-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
14-Aug-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
10-Jun-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
08-Apr-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
04-Mar-2020
Evidence Of Prosecution
Chief Judicial Magistrate
-
03-Feb-2020
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
03-Feb-2020
Case filed
Registration No. 242/2020
Case Summary: C.C. No. 242/2020 Court's Decision: The accused (Ashish Habibbhai Manek, Ramzanbhai Habibbhai Manek, and Mariyamben) were acquitted of charges under IPC Sections 337, 338, 504, 506(2), and 114. The complainant failed to prove the allegations beyond reasonable doubt, as witness testimonies contained significant contradictions and lacked corroboration with the written complaint and medical evidence regarding injuries sustained on December 17, 2019. Key Reasoning: The court found irreconcilable discrepancies between the complainant's and prosecution witnesses' statements regarding the incident details, timing, and injuries. The prosecution's evidence insufficiently established that the accused had intentionally used threatening words or made death threats with the requisite criminal intent required under Section 506(2) IPC. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts