MANUBHA LAKHUBHA CHUDASMA vs DOLUBHA MEPAJIBHAI CHUDASMA1. — 59/2010
Case under Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 31,34,37. Disposed: Contested--DISMISSED on 30th March 2026.
RCS - REGULAR CIVIL SUIT
CNR: GJRJ070000732010
Filing Number
59/2010
Filing Date
13-Oct-2010
Registration No
59/2010
Registration Date
13-Oct-2010
Court
TALUKA COURT, UPLETA
Judge
2-Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
Decision Date
30-Mar-2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--DISMISSED
Last updated 16-May-2026
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.MANUBHA LAKHUBHA CHUDASMA
Adv. D H JOSHI
Respondent(s)
-
1.DOLUBHA MEPAJIBHAI CHUDASMA1.
-
2.CHANDUBHA DOLUBHA CHUDASMA
Adv. K R RANINGA
-
3.MOBATSANG MEPAJIBHAI CHUDASMA(Legal Heir) 2.
-
4.GOVUBHA MOBATSANG CHUDASMA
Adv. K R RANINGA2.
-
5.SUKHDEVSINH MOBATSANG CHUDASMA
Adv. K R RANINGA
-
6.SAJANBEN ALABHAI GARCHAR
Case History
-
Case disposedDisposed
-
30-Mar-2026
JudegementView PDF
CASE SUMMARY Court: Principal Civil Judge, Bhayavadar, Upleta Taluka Case No.: Regular Civil Suit No. 59/2010 Date of Decision: March 30, 2026 Duration: 15 years, 5 months, 17 days Court's Decision The court dismissed the plaintiff's suit with costs to be borne by both parties equally. Key Reasoning: 1. Failure to Establish Essential Facts: The plaintiff failed to prove critical elements of the case: - That the original landowner (Dolubbhai Mepjhibhai) was acting as "Kutumb Karta" (family head) when executing the agreement - That continuous possession of the disputed land remained with the plaintiff since October 15, 1984 - That he had actually performed or remained ready/willing to perform the essential contract terms 2. Statute of Limitations: The plaintiff's claim is barred by the Limitation Act. The alleged agreement was dated October 15, 1984, but the suit was filed on October 13, 2010—26 years later—with no evidence of diligent pursuit of the claim during this period. 3. Estoppel Doctrine: The plaintiff's conduct is barred by the doctrine of estoppel. Despite allegedly owning contractual rights for 26 years, he took no steps to enforce them until 2010, allowing the defendants to act in reliance on the registered sale deed to a third party. 4. Defective Unregistered Agreement: The agreement (Exhibit 63) lacked prescribed stamp duty and was unregistered, making enforcement questionable even on merit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
-
30-Mar-2026
Disposed
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
27-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
23-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
20-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
12-Mar-2026
Final Arguments
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Mar-2026
Defendant Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
05-Mar-2026
Defendant Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
27-Feb-2026
Defendant Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
24-Feb-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Feb-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
19-Feb-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
17-Feb-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Feb-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
19-Jan-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Jan-2026
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
15-Dec-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Dec-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
18-Nov-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
01-Nov-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
16-Oct-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Oct-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
20-Sep-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Sep-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
22-Aug-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
14-Aug-2025
Issues
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Aug-2025
Issues
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
29-Jul-2025
Issues
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
15-Jul-2025
Issues
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
01-Jul-2025
Issues
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
19-Jun-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Jun-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-May-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-May-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
28-Apr-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Apr-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Apr-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Mar-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
05-Mar-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Feb-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
17-Jan-2025
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
24-Dec-2024
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Dec-2024
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Nov-2024
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
25-Oct-2024
Restored
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
25-Oct-2024
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-Nov-2022
OrderView PDF
-
09-Nov-2022
Disposed
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Aug-2022
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
10-May-2022
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Apr-2022
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Mar-2022
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-Feb-2022
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-Dec-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Oct-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Sep-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Sep-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Aug-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-Jul-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-May-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
02-Mar-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Jan-2021
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Dec-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
05-Oct-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Sep-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Jul-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
01-Jun-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Apr-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Feb-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-Jan-2020
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Dec-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-Nov-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
10-Oct-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Sep-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
05-Aug-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Jul-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-May-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Apr-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Mar-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
07-Feb-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-Jan-2019
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
05-Dec-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Oct-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Aug-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
03-Jul-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Addi CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
09-May-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Apr-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Feb-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
17-Jan-2018
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
13-Dec-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Nov-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
20-Sep-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
26-Jul-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
20-Jun-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
14-Jun-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
12-Apr-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
08-Mar-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
15-Feb-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
31-Jan-2017
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
28-Dec-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
23-Nov-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
19-Oct-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
23-Sep-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
26-Aug-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
29-Jul-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
17-Jun-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
22-Apr-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
18-Mar-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
12-Feb-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-Jan-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
02-Jan-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
01-Jan-2016
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
04-Dec-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
23-Oct-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
11-Sep-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
21-Aug-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
17-Jul-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
19-Jun-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
Principal CIVIL Judge & J.M.F.C
-
06-May-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
15-Apr-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
25-Feb-2015
Order Number 1View PDF
-
25-Feb-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
10-Feb-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
22-Jan-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
05-Jan-2015
Plaintiff Evidence
-
09-Dec-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
11-Nov-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
24-Sep-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
02-Sep-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
02-Aug-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
02-Jul-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
12-Jun-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
25-Apr-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
20-Mar-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
25-Feb-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
17-Jan-2014
Plaintiff Evidence
-
17-Dec-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
19-Nov-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
30-Oct-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
13-Sep-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
06-Aug-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
08-Jul-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
17-Jun-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
24-Apr-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
25-Mar-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
21-Feb-2013
Plaintiff Evidence
-
26-Sep-2012
Plaintiff Evidence
-
28-Aug-2012
Plaintiff Evidence
-
23-Jul-2012
Plaintiff Evidence
-
18-Jun-2012
Plaintiff Evidence
-
30-Apr-2012
Plaintiff Evidence
-
16-Mar-2012
—
-
10-Feb-2012
Summons - Notice
-
10-Jan-2012
Summons - Notice
-
12-Dec-2011
Summons - Notice
-
03-Nov-2011
Summons - Notice
-
21-Sep-2011
Summons - Notice
-
12-Aug-2011
Summons - Notice
-
12-Jul-2011
Plaintiff Evidence
-
10-Jun-2011
Plaintiff Evidence
-
13-May-2011
Plaintiff Evidence
-
11-Apr-2011
Plaintiff Evidence
-
11-Mar-2011
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
13-Oct-2010
Case filed
Registration No. 59/2010
CASE SUMMARY Court: Principal Civil Judge, Bhayavadar, Upleta Taluka Case No.: Regular Civil Suit No. 59/2010 Date of Decision: March 30, 2026 Duration: 15 years, 5 months, 17 days Court's Decision The court dismissed the plaintiff's suit with costs to be borne by both parties equally. Key Reasoning: 1. Failure to Establish Essential Facts: The plaintiff failed to prove critical elements of the case: - That the original landowner (Dolubbhai Mepjhibhai) was acting as "Kutumb Karta" (family head) when executing the agreement - That continuous possession of the disputed land remained with the plaintiff since October 15, 1984 - That he had actually performed or remained ready/willing to perform the essential contract terms 2. Statute of Limitations: The plaintiff's claim is barred by the Limitation Act. The alleged agreement was dated October 15, 1984, but the suit was filed on October 13, 2010—26 years later—with no evidence of diligent pursuit of the claim during this period. 3. Estoppel Doctrine: The plaintiff's conduct is barred by the doctrine of estoppel. Despite allegedly owning contractual rights for 26 years, he took no steps to enforce them until 2010, allowing the defendants to act in reliance on the registered sale deed to a third party. 4. Defective Unregistered Agreement: The agreement (Exhibit 63) lacked prescribed stamp duty and was unregistered, making enforcement questionable even on merit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts