THAKOR DARIYABEN WD/O PUNAJI(Legal Heir) vs THAKOR SOLANKI CHHAGANJI DILUJI Advocate - K V SHARMA — 43/2005
Case under Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 163A. Disposed: Contested--PARTLY ALLOWED on 11th March 2026.
MACP - MAC PETITION
CNR: GJPT010000972005
Filing Number
43/2005
Filing Date
27-Jun-2005
Registration No
43/2005
Registration Date
27-Jun-2005
Court
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS COURT PATAN
Judge
1-Principal District & Sessions Judge
Decision Date
11-Mar-2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--PARTLY ALLOWED
Last updated 16-May-2026
FIR Details
Police Station
PATAN TALUKA POLICE STATION - PATAN DISTRICT
Year
0
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
-
1.THAKOR DARIYABEN WD/O PUNAJI(Legal Heir)
Adv. DELETED1.
-
2.MANGIBEN D/O PUNAJI W/O JIVAJI THAKOR
Adv. P J RATHOD
-
3.NARMADABEN URFE NANDABEN D/O PUNAJI W/O VIRAJI THAKOR
Adv. P J RATHOD
-
4.MAGANJI PUNAJI THAKOR
Adv. DELETED
-
5.VIRCHANDJI PUNAJI THAKOR
Adv. DELETED
Respondent(s)
-
1.THAKOR SOLANKI CHHAGANJI DILUJI Advocate - K V SHARMA
-
2.THAKOR SOLANKI CHHAGANJI DILUJI
Adv. K V SHARMA
-
3.ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY
Adv. A M ACHHAVA
Case History
-
Case disposedDisposed
-
11-Mar-2026
JudegementView PDF
Summary The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Patan) awarded ₹1,05,000 in compensation to the legal heirs of deceased Punaji Kuvaraji who died in a jeep accident on 02/11/2004. Under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicle Act (no-fault liability), the tribunal determined compensation based on the deceased's age (70 years) and assessed income (₹27,000 p.a.), applying a multiplier of 5, plus conventional amounts for funeral expenses and loss of estate. The tribunal rejected the insurance company's defense that breach of policy terms (vehicle overloaded beyond seating capacity) exempted liability, finding insufficient evidence to establish the claim. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
-
11-Mar-2026
Disposed
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
05-Mar-2026
Judgement
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
25-Feb-2026
Judgement
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
18-Feb-2026
Final Arguments
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
11-Feb-2026
Applicants Evidence
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
31-Jan-2026
Restored
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
31-Jan-2026
Hearing
Principal District & Sessions Judge
-
03-Dec-2011
Order Number 1
-
03-Dec-2011
Judgement
-
03-Dec-2011
Disposed
-
28-Nov-2011
Judgement
-
25-Nov-2011
Final Arguments
-
19-Oct-2011
Final Arguments
-
13-Oct-2011
Final Arguments
-
14-Sep-2011
Final Arguments
-
26-Aug-2011
Final Arguments
-
06-Aug-2011
Final Arguments
-
13-Jul-2011
Final Arguments
-
20-Jun-2011
Final Arguments
-
13-May-2011
Final Arguments
-
28-Apr-2011
Final Arguments
-
08-Apr-2011
Final Arguments
-
31-Mar-2011
Final Arguments
-
28-Mar-2011
Final Arguments
-
23-Mar-2011
Final Arguments
-
11-Mar-2011
Final Arguments
-
05-Mar-2011
Final Arguments
-
15-Feb-2011
Final Arguments
-
17-Jan-2011
First hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
-
27-Jun-2005
Case filed
Registration No. 43/2005
Summary The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Patan) awarded ₹1,05,000 in compensation to the legal heirs of deceased Punaji Kuvaraji who died in a jeep accident on 02/11/2004. Under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicle Act (no-fault liability), the tribunal determined compensation based on the deceased's age (70 years) and assessed income (₹27,000 p.a.), applying a multiplier of 5, plus conventional amounts for funeral expenses and loss of estate. The tribunal rejected the insurance company's defense that breach of policy terms (vehicle overloaded beyond seating capacity) exempted liability, finding insufficient evidence to establish the claim. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Explore other courts