MANIBEN PARMABHAI MAKWANA vs ARBITRATOR AND COLLECTOR SHREE, PANCHMAHAL Advocate - R S THAKOR — 100/2025
Case under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 29(A)(4)(5). Disposed: Contested--ALLOWED on 29th April 2026.
CMA DC - CIVIL MISC. APPLICATION - DC
CNR: GJPM010036142025
Filing Number
100/2025
Filing Date
07-10-2025
Registration No
100/2025
Registration Date
07-10-2025
Court
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS COURT GODHRA
Judge
6-5th ADDL DISTRICT JUDGE
Decision Date
29th April 2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--ALLOWED
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
MANIBEN PARMABHAI MAKWANA
Adv. H G VIRPURA
PARMABHAI DUDHABHAI MAKWANA
DILIPBHAI MOHANBHAI PARMAR
SHAKRABHAI SOMABHAI KHANT
FATABHAI DABHAIBHAI KHANT
KHATUBHAI HARKHABHAI TIRGAR
BHALABHAI BABARBHAI PARMAR
DHANABHAI SOMABHAI PARMAR
Respondent(s)
ARBITRATOR AND COLLECTOR SHREE, PANCHMAHAL Advocate - R S THAKOR
COMPETENT AND ADDITIONAL SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER
Adv. R S THAKOR
PROJECT DIRECTOR SHREE, NHAI, PIU AHMEDABAD
PIU AHMEDABAD ON BEHALF OF CENTRAL GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAY
Hearing History
Judge: 6-5th ADDL DISTRICT JUDGE
Disposed
ORDER
NOTICE TO OPPONENTS
NOTICE TO OPPONENTS
NOTICE TO OPPONENTS
| Date | Purpose |
|---|---|
| 29-04-2026 | Disposed |
| 18-04-2026 | ORDER |
| 13-03-2026 | NOTICE TO OPPONENTS |
| 13-02-2026 | NOTICE TO OPPONENTS |
| 16-01-2026 | NOTICE TO OPPONENTS |
Final Orders / Judgements
Case Summary: CMA DC No. 100/2025 Court Decision: The 5th Additional District Judge at Godhra granted the farmers' application and extended the Statutory Arbitrator's mandate by one year to complete the compensation dispute proceedings for land acquired for the Ahmedabad-Indore National Highway Project. Key Reasoning: The court found sufficient cause for extension because delays resulted from the arbitrator's administrative duties as Collector (not applicant misconduct), and denying extension would prejudice land-losing farmers and create multiplicity of proceedings. Procedural delays not attributable to parties should not defeat substantial justice. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Case Summary: CMA DC No. 100/2025 Court Decision: The 5th Additional District Judge at Godhra granted the farmers' application and extended the Statutory Arbitrator's mandate by one year to complete the compensation dispute proceedings for land acquired for the Ahmedabad-Indore National Highway Project. Key Reasoning: The court found sufficient cause for extension because delays resulted from the arbitrator's administrative duties as Collector (not applicant misconduct), and denying extension would prejudice land-losing farmers and create multiplicity of proceedings. Procedural delays not attributable to parties should not defeat substantial justice. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Browse Related Cases
Cases under same legislation
Explore other courts