NITABEN PRAFULBHAI SHAH vs NARENDRAKUMAR CHANDUBHAI PATEL Advocate - R R TRIVEDI — 5/2022
Case under Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 39. Status: WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY. Next hearing: 07th July 2026.
RCS - REGULAR CIVIL SUIT
CNR: GJKH080000342022
Next Hearing
07th July 2026
Filing Number
5/2022
Filing Date
04-02-2022
Registration No
5/2022
Registration Date
04-02-2022
Court
TALUKA COURT, KATHLAL
Judge
1-PRINCIPAL CIVIL JUDGE & J.M.F.C
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
NITABEN PRAFULBHAI SHAH
Adv. M.M.KAZI
PUSHPABEN SURESHBHAI ZALA
Adv. M.M.KAZI
Respondent(s)
NARENDRAKUMAR CHANDUBHAI PATEL Advocate - R R TRIVEDI
VIPULBHAI CHANDUBHAI PATEL
Adv. R R TRIVEDI
ASHOKKUMAR KANAIYALA SHAH
Adv. S A KAZI
SURESHBHAI KANAIYALAL SHAH
Adv. S A KAZI
Hearing History
Judge: 1-PRINCIPAL CIVIL JUDGE & J.M.F.C
WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY
WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY
WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY
WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY
WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY
| Date | Purpose |
|---|---|
| 18-05-2026 | WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY |
| 16-03-2026 | WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY |
| 21-01-2026 | WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY |
| 29-12-2025 | WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY |
| 09-12-2025 | WRITTEN STATEMENT/REPLY |
Interim Orders
Case Summary: 5/2022 Court: Additional Civil Judge, Kathlal Parties: Nitaben Prafulbhai Shah & Pushpaben Sureshbhai Zala (Petitioners/Original Plaintiffs) vs. Narendrakumar Chandubhai Patel & others (Respondents/Original Defendants) Outcome: The court rejected the defendants' application under CPC Order-7, Rule-11 seeking dismissal of the plaintiffs' suit. The court held that the plea of *res judicata* (issue already decided) cannot be determined at the preliminary stage under Rule-11, as it requires examination of earlier court judgments and pleadings. Additionally, the court found no valid ground to reject the suit based on limitation or lack of cause of action, as the plaintiffs adequately disclosed their claims regarding disputed road rights and obstruction by defendants. Costs awarded against the defendants. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Case Summary: 5/2022 Court: Additional Civil Judge, Kathlal Parties: Nitaben Prafulbhai Shah & Pushpaben Sureshbhai Zala (Petitioners/Original Plaintiffs) vs. Narendrakumar Chandubhai Patel & others (Respondents/Original Defendants) Outcome: The court rejected the defendants' application under CPC Order-7, Rule-11 seeking dismissal of the plaintiffs' suit. The court held that the plea of *res judicata* (issue already decided) cannot be determined at the preliminary stage under Rule-11, as it requires examination of earlier court judgments and pleadings. Additionally, the court found no valid ground to reject the suit based on limitation or lack of cause of action, as the plaintiffs adequately disclosed their claims regarding disputed road rights and obstruction by defendants. Costs awarded against the defendants. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Browse Related Cases
Cases under same legislation
Explore other courts