DINESHBHAI BACHUBHAI KATHIRIYA vs FULABHAI DAMODARDAS GAJJAR Advocate - R M PATEL — 86/2017

Case under Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 039. Disposed: Contested--REJECTED on 17th March 2026.

Case disposed

SPCS - SPECIAL CIVIL SUIT

CNR: GJKH050029142017

Filing Number

86/2017

Filing Date

18-Nov-2017

Registration No

86/2017

Registration Date

02-Dec-2014

Court

TALUKA COURT, KAPADVANJ

Judge

5-Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

Decision Date

17-Mar-2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--REJECTED

Last updated 16-Jun-2026

Acts & Sections

Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 039

Petitioner(s)

  1. 1.DINESHBHAI BACHUBHAI KATHIRIYA

    Adv. R M PATEL

Respondent(s)

  1. 1.FULABHAI DAMODARDAS GAJJAR Advocate - R M PATEL

  2. 2.NATVARLAL DAMODARDAS GAJJAR

    Adv. D C TALPADA

  3. 3.RATILAL DAMODARDAS GAJJAR

    Adv. D C TALPADA

  4. 4.KAILASHBEN DAMODARDAS GAJJAR

    Adv. D C TALPADA

  5. 5.GAUTAM KISHORBHAI JAYNARAYAN

  6. 6.ASHOKBHAI AMBALAL PATEL

    Adv. D C TALPADA

Case History

  1. Case disposedDisposed

  2. 17-Mar-2026

    JudegementView PDF

    Summary of Case 86/2017 The Additional Senior Civil Judge of Kapadwanj rejected the plaintiff's suit for specific performance of an unregistered agreement to sell dated 13/09/2010 for agricultural land in Village Mirzapur, Kheda District. The court found that the plaintiff failed to prove execution of the alleged agreement (banachitthi) and payment of the claimed earnest money of Rs. 3,00,000. Key deficiencies included: the unregistered nature of the agreement, lack of documentary evidence of payment, absence of a mandatory co-owner's signature, material alterations to the document with different ink, and the plaintiff's failure to prove readiness and willingness to perform. The court upheld the validity of subsequent registered sale deeds executed by the original owners to other parties, finding them to be bona fide purchasers. The suit was barred by limitation as the plaintiff failed to establish it was filed within three years of the defendants' refusal to perform. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

  3. 17-Mar-2026

    Disposed

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  4. 28-Feb-2026

    Judgement

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  5. 21-Feb-2026

    Judgement

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  6. 30-Jan-2026

    Judgement

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  7. 20-Jan-2026

    Judgement

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  8. 22-Dec-2025

    Judgement

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  9. 29-Nov-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  10. 11-Nov-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  11. 16-Oct-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  12. 06-Oct-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  13. 12-Sep-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  14. 04-Sep-2025

    Final Arguments

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  15. 29-Aug-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  16. 19-Aug-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  17. 12-Aug-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  18. 29-Jul-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  19. 14-Jul-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  20. 29-Apr-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  21. 31-Jan-2025

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  22. 27-Dec-2024

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  23. 15-Oct-2024

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  24. 18-Jul-2024

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  25. 26-Apr-2024

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  26. 29-Jan-2024

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  27. 25-Nov-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  28. 23-Sep-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  29. 27-Jul-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    2nd Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  30. 08-Jun-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  31. 13-Apr-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  32. 02-Mar-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  33. 19-Jan-2023

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  34. 03-Dec-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  35. 02-Nov-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  36. 22-Sep-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  37. 25-Aug-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  38. 27-Jul-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  39. 16-Jul-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  40. 24-Jun-2022

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  41. 18-Jun-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  42. 17-May-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  43. 07-May-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  44. 05-May-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  45. 18-Apr-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  46. 07-Apr-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  47. 24-Mar-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  48. 16-Mar-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  49. 03-Mar-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  50. 24-Feb-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  51. 16-Feb-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  52. 27-Jan-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  53. 12-Jan-2022

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  54. 29-Dec-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  55. 09-Dec-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  56. 25-Nov-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  57. 03-Nov-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  58. 13-Oct-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  59. 06-Oct-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  60. 22-Sep-2021

    Defendant Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  61. 09-Sep-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  62. 25-Aug-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  63. 14-Jul-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  64. 16-Jun-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  65. 24-Mar-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  66. 27-Jan-2021

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  67. 12-Nov-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  68. 09-Sep-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  69. 07-Jul-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  70. 14-May-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  71. 18-Mar-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  72. 22-Jan-2020

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  73. 27-Nov-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Addl. Sr. CIVIL Judge & A.C.J.M.

  74. 05-Nov-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

  75. 25-Sep-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  76. 27-Aug-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  77. 17-Jul-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  78. 17-Jun-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  79. 23-Apr-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  80. 18-Mar-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  81. 05-Feb-2019

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  82. 26-Dec-2018

    Plaintiff Evidence

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  83. 19-Nov-2018

    Issues

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  84. 29-Oct-2018

    OrderView PDF

  85. 29-Oct-2018

    Issues

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  86. 08-Oct-2018

    Hearing On Injunction Application

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  87. 18-Sep-2018

    Hearing On Injunction Application

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  88. 14-Aug-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  89. 17-Jul-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  90. 19-Jun-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  91. 08-May-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  92. 30-Apr-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  93. 24-Apr-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  94. 17-Apr-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  95. 04-Apr-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  96. 28-Mar-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  97. 19-Mar-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  98. 26-Feb-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  99. 03-Feb-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  100. 25-Jan-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  101. 09-Jan-2018

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  102. 19-Dec-2017

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  103. 05-Dec-2017

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  104. 21-Nov-2017

    Summons - Notice

    Principal Senior CIVIL Judge

  105. 18-Nov-2017

    First hearing

    Initial hearing scheduled

  106. 18-Nov-2017

    Case filed

    Registration No. 86/2017

casestatus.in Summary

Summary of Case 86/2017 The Additional Senior Civil Judge of Kapadwanj rejected the plaintiff's suit for specific performance of an unregistered agreement to sell dated 13/09/2010 for agricultural land in Village Mirzapur, Kheda District. The court found that the plaintiff failed to prove execution of the alleged agreement (banachitthi) and payment of the claimed earnest money of Rs. 3,00,000. Key deficiencies included: the unregistered nature of the agreement, lack of documentary evidence of payment, absence of a mandatory co-owner's signature, material alterations to the document with different ink, and the plaintiff's failure to prove readiness and willingness to perform. The court upheld the validity of subsequent registered sale deeds executed by the original owners to other parties, finding them to be bona fide purchasers. The suit was barred by limitation as the plaintiff failed to establish it was filed within three years of the defendants' refusal to perform. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Explore other courts

High Courts Supreme Court
Search Another Case