RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS vs NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS — WP/5498/2026
Case under Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section NA. Disposed: Contested--Disposed Off on 07th May 2026.
CNR: HCBM010202042026
Filing Number
WP/11757/2026
Filing Date
21-04-2026
Registration No
WP/5498/2026
Registration Date
22-04-2026
Judge
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE
Coram
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE
Bench Type
Single
Category
RENT ACT ( 34 )
Sub-Category
OTHERS ( 99 )
Judicial Branch
Civil
Decision Date
07th May 2026
Nature of Disposal
Contested--Disposed Off
Acts & Sections
Petitioner(s)
RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS
Adv. Jaydeep Deo
VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA
SARASWATI MOHATTA CHIKITSA NYAS A CHARITABLE
R.B. SETH SHIVRATAN GOVERDHANDAS MOHATTA TRUST
SIVRATAN G. MOHATTA PROPRITARY OF VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA
Respondent(s)
NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS
NADEEM MAJID OOMERBHOY
HEENA MAJID OOMERBHOY
CHRISTA MISTRY
KUSUM RAHIM KARIM MISTRY
AYAZ RAHIM KARIM MISTRY
TALASIM PESHIMAN
BILKIZ IQBAL ALADIN
SHAHINDA SHABAN CURRIM
PARVEZ NOORUDDIN IBRAHIM
BHARATI CELLULAR LTD
SHAIKH REHANA AND RAMEEZ R. AHMED
ANEHA RAJESH NAGPAL
RAVIN TRADING CO.
DAYAJEE AND CO.
K S LAKHANI AND S SIDDIQUE
NOOR M AND M. SIDDIQUE
BANSILAL BEHARILAL
JP GEHI, SMT. N H GEHI
GLOBE ENTERPRISES (INDIA)
DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASEED
SONTA RAJU LALCHANDANI
RAJAN A, THAKKAR
MAHARASHTRA PENCIAL FACTORY
O.K. SILK PALACE
GANESH KUPPUSWAMY
SANJAY RAJEEV AND L N KHANA
GANESH K. SWAMY
HITESH T AND NH TAHILIANI
PRADEEP P. LALWANI
JAYWANT MIRCHANDANI
RESHMA MOHAN BHATIA
DAULATRAM T. ASHWANI
LALCHAND MOHANDAS GANGANI
ISHWARLAL MOHANDAS GANGWANI
LAVIN T AND DILIP L. TAHILIANI
GULAB K. JESWANI
K L KIRPALANI
PREM TEXTILE
P VIJAY KUMAR
DAULATRAM BHERUMAL SAMWANI
SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI
V BULCHANDANI AND K P BULCHANDANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI
KANTA K KRIPLANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI
CHETANDAS D AND K C PANJANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI
SHARAFAT INTERNATIONAL
KISHAN LACHANDAS
ABDUL BASHEER
BHAGWAN K. NANKANI
KISHORE AND P KINGER
KAUSHILA C AND VIJAY C PANJAWANI
JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT
SUNITA ROOP MADHARANI
K.S. BHATIA S B BHATIA
MOHAMMED ARSHAD KARIM
JAVED A AND NAHEED MERCHANT
MANOJ M BHATIA
S.V. BHATIA AND L P GANGWANI
JATUBHA J JADEJA
VINOD VASHDEV NAGPAL
VISHNU M. BANIYANI
NIRMAL BANVANI
RITA JAGDISH BHATIA
GOPAL M PUNJABI
DHIRAJLAL VELJI AND SHARDA VP
SHABNA HAMID
NARAYAN S. SHETTY
MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL
SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI
KANAYALAL R HASSIJA
SHASHIKANT DUGARSHI SHAH
MOHAMEDALI FAIKH
MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL
SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI
KANAYALAL R HASSIJA
SHASHIKANT DUNGARSHI SHAH
MOHAMEDALI FAIKH
MEMUNA MOHD AHMED PATEL
LOMOPDKANWAR J SODHA
POONAM KISHOR KINGER
VISHANDAS K CHUGH
RAFIQ ABDULKADAR SAYED
SUNIL KISHORE KINGER
K.L. MALHOTRA BROS
LALCHAND K JETHANI
VIJAY TRADING CO.
MURLIDHAR T TILWANI
BIAND KNITWEAR
V.R. MEHTA
ALPHA IMPEX CORPN
BHAGWANDS V AND J V CHELLANI
MAHESH K AND BEENA M SACHDEV
APSARA SILK CORNER
SULEMAN MOHD AYUB
T. KISHANCHAND
YUNUSALI B SAYYAD
TAKAMDAS AND SONS
DHALOMAL MANGHMAL ESQ
SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI
JJB AND CJ BHAGOHANDANI
MAMTA SAREE CENTRE
ROSHAN STORE
PREMJITHANAND AND JYOTIPREM GEHI
SARDAR SAREE CENTRE
AMBICA SILK STORES
US DEDHIA AND VS DEDHIA
TULSIDAS MENGHANDAS
BHAGWANDAS DASOMAL AND CO.
KUMAR BROS
CHANDRU FANCY STORE
GHANSHYAM SAREE CENTRE
RAMCHAND MONAHDAS
BHAGWANDAS AND CO.
JANATBEE B AND Y B SAYYED
JOGA NAGA MOGAVEERA
K.D. SACHDEV
SONMARG CUT PIECE CENTRE
TAHER MOHAMAD MOOSA KAPADIA
DHARAMDAS CHHABILDAS
PARVEZ AND HAFSABEE MD ALI FAKIH
ABBASALI AHMEDALI LUNJE
VINOD FANCY STORES
BALIRAM TRIKAMDAS
AHMEDALI A. LUNJE
MUNSHI ABDUL SHAKODAR ANSARI
NADIRA IMRAN KHAN
SULEMAN A R KERAWALA
KANNY CORNER
MOHINI SILK STORE
ABDUL GAFFAR A KARIM SUMAR
MONARCH REALTORS PVT. LTD
A HAMEED C MANIYAR A H MANSYAR
KASHINATH S. KAPOOR
BJ SARVAIYA
B.S. MOHATA
RAMESH GAGANMAL AHUJA
SHRIB S. MOHATTA
MOHAN PEHLAJDAS MULTANI
J.K. AND HARESH K. KUKREJA
ABDUL RASHID E SHIAKH
ADISHERIAR GILANI IRANI
A.M. ZARIWALA
SHALIMAR EMBROIDERS
ASSANDAS FATANDAS ESQ
STAR TAILOR
SHOBA VISHINDAS CHUGH
PURAV DRESS MATERIALS
VISHINDAS TULSIDAS SOMAYA
MAYURKALA GEMS
MOHD SIDDIQUE AHMED THEBAL
BHARAT EMBROIDERS AND TAILORS
HAJI MOHAMMED JNMD AND PEERZADA
MAVHIND CLOTH STORE
SHAIKH R R A AND F S AHMED
MUNSHI ABDUL S. ANSARI
MEMUNA MOHAMMED AND AHMED PATEL
SATPALSINGH P.V. UPPAL
S PARMJEET SINGH ARORA
VARSHA MOHAN MULTANI
COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES
B.R. CHAWADA
MOHAMAD SHAFI HAJI UMAR
DAULAT CLOTH STORES
ABDUL AZIZ HASHAN FRUITWALA
FARISA A.R. PATEL
MONICA SAREE CENTER
MAHARASHTRA PENCIL FACTORY
ELITE ELECTRIC CO.
KAMPDKANWAR JEETUSINGH SODHA
MAFIDEVI MERERAM MALI
PARAS KANWER W/O S S RATHOD
HEMA AM
PAWASKAR ENGINEERS
NARAINDAS D. LAKHANI
ANSARI AKBARALI FUZAIL AHMED
S N SAREE CENTRE
ANIL MAHATANI
C.S. DHANU
CHELARAM AND MERARAM V MALI
SUNITA BHAGWANDAS
KUMPSINGH SODHA
LAKSHMANS
NISHA BUDHRANI
BJ BHAGCHANDANI AND RB BHAGCHANDANI
BIDHRANI PURSHOTTAM
NAHEED J MERCHANT AND J A MERCHANT
ANSARI AKHTARALI FUZAIL AHMED
RIYAZALI JABBARALI SHEIKH
MAFIDEVI MERARAM MALI
LALCHAND D AND RAJKUMARI L. SHROFF
SOHALI AHMED ABDULMALIK JAVERI
SHABIR ABDULLAH NAVIWALLA
SONAL STEEL SYNDICATE
NADIRA IMRAN KHAN
JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT
HARISH T MANUJA
GAJARA SHYAM B
MOHD A K I AHMED KHAN
RAJESH B AND RAMESH B NAGPAL
VIJAY TRADING CO.
RAMCHAND K VIJLA
JAVEED A MERCHANT
JETHANAND BULCHAND
MEHBOO SHAIKH
MITRA STORES
AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI
AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI
GOKULDAS PHERUMAL
SHAIKH RAEES A AND SHAIKH S A
ISAJANDAS KEWALRAMI ESQ
VINOD V AND MONA V NAGPAL
N. AEWANDRAM N. VACANI
NANDLAL N. MUTREJA
OMPRAKASH JAIRAMDAS KHORMAL
GOKALDAS PHERULAL ESQ
R. DAMOMAL
NASREEN TEXTILES
PREM'S
SELETION SILK HOUSE
PRAKASH NEWANDRAM VENGANI
CHANDRA TRIKAMDAS
SHRIJRAM J. PUNJABI
SAWLARAM AND K S MALI
LEKHWAJ ASSUDOMAL
ABDUL GAFFER ABDUL KARIM
GOPIBAI D AND P HOLCHAND
JANKI NICHALDAS
DHULAMAL BROTHERS
ABDUL ALEEM CHUNNUMIYA MANIYAR
N.B.M. QURESHI AND S.A.B. MANDAI
MOHANDAS AWTRAM ESQ
MULCHAND KARMZMAL CHUGH
GOKULDAS PHERUMAL
NATIONAL STORES
SURESH V BHATIA
HAYAT
KHUBCHAND SEWARAM
KISHANCHAND DASMAL
PARTABHAI MITHUMAL ESQ
RIJHUMAL AND CO.
S.N. NARIWALA
DUNDERDAS AND ATMARAM J PUNJABI
LOVLY SILK HOUSE
RAMCHAND SONS
CHANDOO
RAJULA AND ROHIT LALCHANDANI
ISMAIL MA AIBANI AND A R HASHAM
RAMESH STORES
FARIDA EBRAHIM BADSHAH
L.K. ANANDINI
MATLOOB REHMAN
MEHRUNNISSA A R MANIYAR
MOHD. IMTIAZ HAJI AGEWAN
CHELA RAM KEWAL RAM P. SHANKAR
RITU SHARVAN GIRI
ISMAIL BILAL KAPADIA
LAVIN AND HITESH TAHILIANI
MASHKORR AHMED FAROOQUI
CHELARAM M. RAJNANI
A GAFFAR BHARUCHI
SANGITA R JETHANANI
SHAIKH R AHMED AND SHABBIR AHMED
LALCHAND AND BROTHERS
FANCY BHIMRAJI BAGERCHA
MOHD YAQOB MEHMOOD MIYA QURES
SAYYED BAKER
RAM CLOTH STORES
H.A. JABBAR
ALI AHMED SIDDIQUE
PREM ISRANI
MOHD SIDDIQUE S/O HAJI A
LACHHAMANDAS AND SONS
SALIM AHMED SORATHIA
ZULFIKAR KAYUMALI UDAIPURWALA
ZAIBUNISA MOHAMED IQBAL ADVANI
DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASHEED
BUSINESS TRACKERS, PRATHAMESH CHS LTD.
Hearing History
Judge: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE
FOR CIRCULATION
| Date | Purpose |
|---|---|
| 23-04-2026 | FOR CIRCULATION |
Orders
Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.
Browse Related Cases
Cases under same legislation
Explore other courts