RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS vs NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS — WP/5498/2026

Case under Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section NA. Disposed: Contested--Disposed Off on 07th May 2026.

CNR: HCBM010202042026

CASE DISPOSED

Filing Number

WP/11757/2026

Filing Date

21-04-2026

Registration No

WP/5498/2026

Registration Date

22-04-2026

Judge

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE

Coram

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE

Bench Type

Single

Category

RENT ACT ( 34 )

Sub-Category

OTHERS ( 99 )

Judicial Branch

Civil

Decision Date

07th May 2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--Disposed Off

Acts & Sections

Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section NA

Petitioner(s)

RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS

Adv. Jaydeep Deo

VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA

SARASWATI MOHATTA CHIKITSA NYAS A CHARITABLE

R.B. SETH SHIVRATAN GOVERDHANDAS MOHATTA TRUST

SIVRATAN G. MOHATTA PROPRITARY OF VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA

Respondent(s)

NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS

NADEEM MAJID OOMERBHOY

HEENA MAJID OOMERBHOY

CHRISTA MISTRY

KUSUM RAHIM KARIM MISTRY

AYAZ RAHIM KARIM MISTRY

TALASIM PESHIMAN

BILKIZ IQBAL ALADIN

SHAHINDA SHABAN CURRIM

PARVEZ NOORUDDIN IBRAHIM

BHARATI CELLULAR LTD

SHAIKH REHANA AND RAMEEZ R. AHMED

ANEHA RAJESH NAGPAL

RAVIN TRADING CO.

DAYAJEE AND CO.

K S LAKHANI AND S SIDDIQUE

NOOR M AND M. SIDDIQUE

BANSILAL BEHARILAL

JP GEHI, SMT. N H GEHI

GLOBE ENTERPRISES (INDIA)

DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASEED

SONTA RAJU LALCHANDANI

RAJAN A, THAKKAR

MAHARASHTRA PENCIAL FACTORY

O.K. SILK PALACE

GANESH KUPPUSWAMY

SANJAY RAJEEV AND L N KHANA

GANESH K. SWAMY

HITESH T AND NH TAHILIANI

PRADEEP P. LALWANI

JAYWANT MIRCHANDANI

RESHMA MOHAN BHATIA

DAULATRAM T. ASHWANI

LALCHAND MOHANDAS GANGANI

ISHWARLAL MOHANDAS GANGWANI

LAVIN T AND DILIP L. TAHILIANI

GULAB K. JESWANI

K L KIRPALANI

PREM TEXTILE

P VIJAY KUMAR

DAULATRAM BHERUMAL SAMWANI

SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI

V BULCHANDANI AND K P BULCHANDANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

KANTA K KRIPLANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

CHETANDAS D AND K C PANJANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

SHARAFAT INTERNATIONAL

KISHAN LACHANDAS

ABDUL BASHEER

BHAGWAN K. NANKANI

KISHORE AND P KINGER

KAUSHILA C AND VIJAY C PANJAWANI

JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT

SUNITA ROOP MADHARANI

K.S. BHATIA S B BHATIA

MOHAMMED ARSHAD KARIM

JAVED A AND NAHEED MERCHANT

MANOJ M BHATIA

S.V. BHATIA AND L P GANGWANI

JATUBHA J JADEJA

VINOD VASHDEV NAGPAL

VISHNU M. BANIYANI

NIRMAL BANVANI

RITA JAGDISH BHATIA

GOPAL M PUNJABI

DHIRAJLAL VELJI AND SHARDA VP

SHABNA HAMID

NARAYAN S. SHETTY

MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL

SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI

KANAYALAL R HASSIJA

SHASHIKANT DUGARSHI SHAH

MOHAMEDALI FAIKH

MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL

SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI

KANAYALAL R HASSIJA

SHASHIKANT DUNGARSHI SHAH

MOHAMEDALI FAIKH

MEMUNA MOHD AHMED PATEL

LOMOPDKANWAR J SODHA

POONAM KISHOR KINGER

VISHANDAS K CHUGH

RAFIQ ABDULKADAR SAYED

SUNIL KISHORE KINGER

K.L. MALHOTRA BROS

LALCHAND K JETHANI

VIJAY TRADING CO.

MURLIDHAR T TILWANI

BIAND KNITWEAR

V.R. MEHTA

ALPHA IMPEX CORPN

BHAGWANDS V AND J V CHELLANI

MAHESH K AND BEENA M SACHDEV

APSARA SILK CORNER

SULEMAN MOHD AYUB

T. KISHANCHAND

YUNUSALI B SAYYAD

TAKAMDAS AND SONS

DHALOMAL MANGHMAL ESQ

SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI

JJB AND CJ BHAGOHANDANI

MAMTA SAREE CENTRE

ROSHAN STORE

PREMJITHANAND AND JYOTIPREM GEHI

SARDAR SAREE CENTRE

AMBICA SILK STORES

US DEDHIA AND VS DEDHIA

TULSIDAS MENGHANDAS

BHAGWANDAS DASOMAL AND CO.

KUMAR BROS

CHANDRU FANCY STORE

GHANSHYAM SAREE CENTRE

RAMCHAND MONAHDAS

BHAGWANDAS AND CO.

JANATBEE B AND Y B SAYYED

JOGA NAGA MOGAVEERA

K.D. SACHDEV

SONMARG CUT PIECE CENTRE

TAHER MOHAMAD MOOSA KAPADIA

DHARAMDAS CHHABILDAS

PARVEZ AND HAFSABEE MD ALI FAKIH

ABBASALI AHMEDALI LUNJE

VINOD FANCY STORES

BALIRAM TRIKAMDAS

AHMEDALI A. LUNJE

MUNSHI ABDUL SHAKODAR ANSARI

NADIRA IMRAN KHAN

SULEMAN A R KERAWALA

KANNY CORNER

MOHINI SILK STORE

ABDUL GAFFAR A KARIM SUMAR

MONARCH REALTORS PVT. LTD

A HAMEED C MANIYAR A H MANSYAR

KASHINATH S. KAPOOR

BJ SARVAIYA

B.S. MOHATA

RAMESH GAGANMAL AHUJA

SHRIB S. MOHATTA

MOHAN PEHLAJDAS MULTANI

J.K. AND HARESH K. KUKREJA

ABDUL RASHID E SHIAKH

ADISHERIAR GILANI IRANI

A.M. ZARIWALA

SHALIMAR EMBROIDERS

ASSANDAS FATANDAS ESQ

STAR TAILOR

SHOBA VISHINDAS CHUGH

PURAV DRESS MATERIALS

VISHINDAS TULSIDAS SOMAYA

MAYURKALA GEMS

MOHD SIDDIQUE AHMED THEBAL

BHARAT EMBROIDERS AND TAILORS

HAJI MOHAMMED JNMD AND PEERZADA

MAVHIND CLOTH STORE

SHAIKH R R A AND F S AHMED

MUNSHI ABDUL S. ANSARI

MEMUNA MOHAMMED AND AHMED PATEL

SATPALSINGH P.V. UPPAL

S PARMJEET SINGH ARORA

VARSHA MOHAN MULTANI

COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES

B.R. CHAWADA

MOHAMAD SHAFI HAJI UMAR

DAULAT CLOTH STORES

ABDUL AZIZ HASHAN FRUITWALA

FARISA A.R. PATEL

MONICA SAREE CENTER

MAHARASHTRA PENCIL FACTORY

ELITE ELECTRIC CO.

KAMPDKANWAR JEETUSINGH SODHA

MAFIDEVI MERERAM MALI

PARAS KANWER W/O S S RATHOD

HEMA AM

PAWASKAR ENGINEERS

NARAINDAS D. LAKHANI

ANSARI AKBARALI FUZAIL AHMED

S N SAREE CENTRE

ANIL MAHATANI

C.S. DHANU

CHELARAM AND MERARAM V MALI

SUNITA BHAGWANDAS

KUMPSINGH SODHA

LAKSHMANS

NISHA BUDHRANI

BJ BHAGCHANDANI AND RB BHAGCHANDANI

BIDHRANI PURSHOTTAM

NAHEED J MERCHANT AND J A MERCHANT

ANSARI AKHTARALI FUZAIL AHMED

RIYAZALI JABBARALI SHEIKH

MAFIDEVI MERARAM MALI

LALCHAND D AND RAJKUMARI L. SHROFF

SOHALI AHMED ABDULMALIK JAVERI

SHABIR ABDULLAH NAVIWALLA

SONAL STEEL SYNDICATE

NADIRA IMRAN KHAN

JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT

HARISH T MANUJA

GAJARA SHYAM B

MOHD A K I AHMED KHAN

RAJESH B AND RAMESH B NAGPAL

VIJAY TRADING CO.

RAMCHAND K VIJLA

JAVEED A MERCHANT

JETHANAND BULCHAND

MEHBOO SHAIKH

MITRA STORES

AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI

AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI

GOKULDAS PHERUMAL

SHAIKH RAEES A AND SHAIKH S A

ISAJANDAS KEWALRAMI ESQ

VINOD V AND MONA V NAGPAL

N. AEWANDRAM N. VACANI

NANDLAL N. MUTREJA

OMPRAKASH JAIRAMDAS KHORMAL

GOKALDAS PHERULAL ESQ

R. DAMOMAL

NASREEN TEXTILES

PREM'S

SELETION SILK HOUSE

PRAKASH NEWANDRAM VENGANI

CHANDRA TRIKAMDAS

SHRIJRAM J. PUNJABI

SAWLARAM AND K S MALI

LEKHWAJ ASSUDOMAL

ABDUL GAFFER ABDUL KARIM

GOPIBAI D AND P HOLCHAND

JANKI NICHALDAS

DHULAMAL BROTHERS

ABDUL ALEEM CHUNNUMIYA MANIYAR

N.B.M. QURESHI AND S.A.B. MANDAI

MOHANDAS AWTRAM ESQ

MULCHAND KARMZMAL CHUGH

GOKULDAS PHERUMAL

NATIONAL STORES

SURESH V BHATIA

HAYAT

KHUBCHAND SEWARAM

KISHANCHAND DASMAL

PARTABHAI MITHUMAL ESQ

RIJHUMAL AND CO.

S.N. NARIWALA

DUNDERDAS AND ATMARAM J PUNJABI

LOVLY SILK HOUSE

RAMCHAND SONS

CHANDOO

RAJULA AND ROHIT LALCHANDANI

ISMAIL MA AIBANI AND A R HASHAM

RAMESH STORES

FARIDA EBRAHIM BADSHAH

L.K. ANANDINI

MATLOOB REHMAN

MEHRUNNISSA A R MANIYAR

MOHD. IMTIAZ HAJI AGEWAN

CHELA RAM KEWAL RAM P. SHANKAR

RITU SHARVAN GIRI

ISMAIL BILAL KAPADIA

LAVIN AND HITESH TAHILIANI

MASHKORR AHMED FAROOQUI

CHELARAM M. RAJNANI

A GAFFAR BHARUCHI

SANGITA R JETHANANI

SHAIKH R AHMED AND SHABBIR AHMED

LALCHAND AND BROTHERS

FANCY BHIMRAJI BAGERCHA

MOHD YAQOB MEHMOOD MIYA QURES

SAYYED BAKER

RAM CLOTH STORES

H.A. JABBAR

ALI AHMED SIDDIQUE

PREM ISRANI

MOHD SIDDIQUE S/O HAJI A

LACHHAMANDAS AND SONS

SALIM AHMED SORATHIA

ZULFIKAR KAYUMALI UDAIPURWALA

ZAIBUNISA MOHAMED IQBAL ADVANI

DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASHEED

BUSINESS TRACKERS, PRATHAMESH CHS LTD.

Hearing History

Judge: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE

23-04-2026

FOR CIRCULATION

Orders

07-05-2026
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE

Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

casestatus.in Summary

Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Browse Related Cases

Cases under same legislation

Explore other courts

Search Another Case