RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS vs NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS — WP/5498/2026

Case under Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section NA. Disposed: Contested--Disposed Off on 07th May 2026.

Case disposed

CNR: HCBM010202042026

Filing Number

WP/11757/2026

Filing Date

21-Apr-2026

Registration No

WP/5498/2026

Registration Date

22-Apr-2026

Judge

Hon'ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. Marne

Coram

Hon'ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. Marne

Bench Type

Single

Category

RENT ACT ( 34 )

Sub-Category

OTHERS ( 99 )

Judicial Branch

Civil

Decision Date

07-May-2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--Disposed Off

Last updated 28-May-2026

Acts & Sections

Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section NA

Petitioner(s)

  1. 1.RAJENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA AND ORS

    Adv. Jaydeep Deo

  2. 2.VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA

  3. 3.SARASWATI MOHATTA CHIKITSA NYAS A CHARITABLE

  4. 4.R.B. SETH SHIVRATAN GOVERDHANDAS MOHATTA TRUST

  5. 5.SIVRATAN G. MOHATTA PROPRITARY OF VIRENDRA KUMAR MOHATTA

Respondent(s)

  1. 1.NARGIS MAJID OOMERBHOY AND ORS

  2. 2.NADEEM MAJID OOMERBHOY

  3. 3.HEENA MAJID OOMERBHOY

  4. 4.CHRISTA MISTRY

  5. 5.KUSUM RAHIM KARIM MISTRY

  6. 6.AYAZ RAHIM KARIM MISTRY

  7. 7.TALASIM PESHIMAN

  8. 8.BILKIZ IQBAL ALADIN

  9. 9.SHAHINDA SHABAN CURRIM

  10. 10.PARVEZ NOORUDDIN IBRAHIM

  11. 11.BHARATI CELLULAR LTD

  12. 12.SHAIKH REHANA AND RAMEEZ R. AHMED

  13. 13.ANEHA RAJESH NAGPAL

  14. 14.RAVIN TRADING CO.

  15. 15.DAYAJEE AND CO.

  16. 16.K S LAKHANI AND S SIDDIQUE

  17. 17.NOOR M AND M. SIDDIQUE

  18. 18.BANSILAL BEHARILAL

  19. 19.JP GEHI, SMT. N H GEHI

  20. 20.GLOBE ENTERPRISES (INDIA)

  21. 21.DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASEED

  22. 22.SONTA RAJU LALCHANDANI

  23. 23.RAJAN A, THAKKAR

  24. 24.MAHARASHTRA PENCIAL FACTORY

  25. 25.O.K. SILK PALACE

  26. 26.GANESH KUPPUSWAMY

  27. 27.SANJAY RAJEEV AND L N KHANA

  28. 28.GANESH K. SWAMY

  29. 29.HITESH T AND NH TAHILIANI

  30. 30.PRADEEP P. LALWANI

  31. 31.JAYWANT MIRCHANDANI

  32. 32.RESHMA MOHAN BHATIA

  33. 33.DAULATRAM T. ASHWANI

  34. 34.LALCHAND MOHANDAS GANGANI

  35. 35.ISHWARLAL MOHANDAS GANGWANI

  36. 36.LAVIN T AND DILIP L. TAHILIANI

  37. 37.GULAB K. JESWANI

  38. 38.K L KIRPALANI

  39. 39.PREM TEXTILE

  40. 40.P VIJAY KUMAR

  41. 41.DAULATRAM BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  42. 42.SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  43. 43.V BULCHANDANI AND K P BULCHANDANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  44. 44.KANTA K KRIPLANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  45. 45.CHETANDAS D AND K C PANJANI BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  46. 46.SHARAFAT INTERNATIONAL

  47. 47.KISHAN LACHANDAS

  48. 48.ABDUL BASHEER

  49. 49.BHAGWAN K. NANKANI

  50. 50.KISHORE AND P KINGER

  51. 51.KAUSHILA C AND VIJAY C PANJAWANI

  52. 52.JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT

  53. 53.SUNITA ROOP MADHARANI

  54. 54.K.S. BHATIA S B BHATIA

  55. 55.MOHAMMED ARSHAD KARIM

  56. 56.JAVED A AND NAHEED MERCHANT

  57. 57.MANOJ M BHATIA

  58. 58.S.V. BHATIA AND L P GANGWANI

  59. 59.JATUBHA J JADEJA

  60. 60.VINOD VASHDEV NAGPAL

  61. 61.VISHNU M. BANIYANI

  62. 62.NIRMAL BANVANI

  63. 63.RITA JAGDISH BHATIA

  64. 64.GOPAL M PUNJABI

  65. 65.DHIRAJLAL VELJI AND SHARDA VP

  66. 66.SHABNA HAMID

  67. 67.NARAYAN S. SHETTY

  68. 68.MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL

  69. 69.SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI

  70. 70.KANAYALAL R HASSIJA

  71. 71.SHASHIKANT DUGARSHI SHAH

  72. 72.MOHAMEDALI FAIKH

  73. 73.MOHMEDUSMAN PATEL

  74. 74.SHRIFA S. LAKHANI AND F M ZAVERI

  75. 75.KANAYALAL R HASSIJA

  76. 76.SHASHIKANT DUNGARSHI SHAH

  77. 77.MOHAMEDALI FAIKH

  78. 78.MEMUNA MOHD AHMED PATEL

  79. 79.LOMOPDKANWAR J SODHA

  80. 80.POONAM KISHOR KINGER

  81. 81.VISHANDAS K CHUGH

  82. 82.RAFIQ ABDULKADAR SAYED

  83. 83.SUNIL KISHORE KINGER

  84. 84.K.L. MALHOTRA BROS

  85. 85.LALCHAND K JETHANI

  86. 86.VIJAY TRADING CO.

  87. 87.MURLIDHAR T TILWANI

  88. 88.BIAND KNITWEAR

  89. 89.V.R. MEHTA

  90. 90.ALPHA IMPEX CORPN

  91. 91.BHAGWANDS V AND J V CHELLANI

  92. 92.MAHESH K AND BEENA M SACHDEV

  93. 93.APSARA SILK CORNER

  94. 94.SULEMAN MOHD AYUB

  95. 95.T. KISHANCHAND

  96. 96.YUNUSALI B SAYYAD

  97. 97.TAKAMDAS AND SONS

  98. 98.DHALOMAL MANGHMAL ESQ

  99. 99.SHAMDAS BHERUMAL SAMWANI

  100. 100.JJB AND CJ BHAGOHANDANI

  101. 101.MAMTA SAREE CENTRE

  102. 102.ROSHAN STORE

  103. 103.PREMJITHANAND AND JYOTIPREM GEHI

  104. 104.SARDAR SAREE CENTRE

  105. 105.AMBICA SILK STORES

  106. 106.US DEDHIA AND VS DEDHIA

  107. 107.TULSIDAS MENGHANDAS

  108. 108.BHAGWANDAS DASOMAL AND CO.

  109. 109.KUMAR BROS

  110. 110.CHANDRU FANCY STORE

  111. 111.GHANSHYAM SAREE CENTRE

  112. 112.RAMCHAND MONAHDAS

  113. 113.BHAGWANDAS AND CO.

  114. 114.JANATBEE B AND Y B SAYYED

  115. 115.JOGA NAGA MOGAVEERA

  116. 116.K.D. SACHDEV

  117. 117.SONMARG CUT PIECE CENTRE

  118. 118.TAHER MOHAMAD MOOSA KAPADIA

  119. 119.DHARAMDAS CHHABILDAS

  120. 120.PARVEZ AND HAFSABEE MD ALI FAKIH

  121. 121.ABBASALI AHMEDALI LUNJE

  122. 122.VINOD FANCY STORES

  123. 123.BALIRAM TRIKAMDAS

  124. 124.AHMEDALI A. LUNJE

  125. 125.MUNSHI ABDUL SHAKODAR ANSARI

  126. 126.NADIRA IMRAN KHAN

  127. 127.SULEMAN A R KERAWALA

  128. 128.KANNY CORNER

  129. 129.MOHINI SILK STORE

  130. 130.ABDUL GAFFAR A KARIM SUMAR

  131. 131.MONARCH REALTORS PVT. LTD

  132. 132.A HAMEED C MANIYAR A H MANSYAR

  133. 133.KASHINATH S. KAPOOR

  134. 134.BJ SARVAIYA

  135. 135.B.S. MOHATA

  136. 136.RAMESH GAGANMAL AHUJA

  137. 137.SHRIB S. MOHATTA

  138. 138.MOHAN PEHLAJDAS MULTANI

  139. 139.J.K. AND HARESH K. KUKREJA

  140. 140.ABDUL RASHID E SHIAKH

  141. 141.ADISHERIAR GILANI IRANI

  142. 142.A.M. ZARIWALA

  143. 143.SHALIMAR EMBROIDERS

  144. 144.ASSANDAS FATANDAS ESQ

  145. 145.STAR TAILOR

  146. 146.SHOBA VISHINDAS CHUGH

  147. 147.PURAV DRESS MATERIALS

  148. 148.VISHINDAS TULSIDAS SOMAYA

  149. 149.MAYURKALA GEMS

  150. 150.MOHD SIDDIQUE AHMED THEBAL

  151. 151.BHARAT EMBROIDERS AND TAILORS

  152. 152.HAJI MOHAMMED JNMD AND PEERZADA

  153. 153.MAVHIND CLOTH STORE

  154. 154.SHAIKH R R A AND F S AHMED

  155. 155.MUNSHI ABDUL S. ANSARI

  156. 156.MEMUNA MOHAMMED AND AHMED PATEL

  157. 157.SATPALSINGH P.V. UPPAL

  158. 158.S PARMJEET SINGH ARORA

  159. 159.VARSHA MOHAN MULTANI

  160. 160.COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES

  161. 161.B.R. CHAWADA

  162. 162.MOHAMAD SHAFI HAJI UMAR

  163. 163.DAULAT CLOTH STORES

  164. 164.ABDUL AZIZ HASHAN FRUITWALA

  165. 165.FARISA A.R. PATEL

  166. 166.MONICA SAREE CENTER

  167. 167.MAHARASHTRA PENCIL FACTORY

  168. 168.ELITE ELECTRIC CO.

  169. 169.KAMPDKANWAR JEETUSINGH SODHA

  170. 170.MAFIDEVI MERERAM MALI

  171. 171.PARAS KANWER W/O S S RATHOD

  172. 172.HEMA AM

  173. 173.PAWASKAR ENGINEERS

  174. 174.NARAINDAS D. LAKHANI

  175. 175.ANSARI AKBARALI FUZAIL AHMED

  176. 176.S N SAREE CENTRE

  177. 177.ANIL MAHATANI

  178. 178.C.S. DHANU

  179. 179.CHELARAM AND MERARAM V MALI

  180. 180.SUNITA BHAGWANDAS

  181. 181.KUMPSINGH SODHA

  182. 182.LAKSHMANS

  183. 183.NISHA BUDHRANI

  184. 184.BJ BHAGCHANDANI AND RB BHAGCHANDANI

  185. 185.BIDHRANI PURSHOTTAM

  186. 186.NAHEED J MERCHANT AND J A MERCHANT

  187. 187.ANSARI AKHTARALI FUZAIL AHMED

  188. 188.RIYAZALI JABBARALI SHEIKH

  189. 189.MAFIDEVI MERARAM MALI

  190. 190.LALCHAND D AND RAJKUMARI L. SHROFF

  191. 191.SOHALI AHMED ABDULMALIK JAVERI

  192. 192.SHABIR ABDULLAH NAVIWALLA

  193. 193.SONAL STEEL SYNDICATE

  194. 194.NADIRA IMRAN KHAN

  195. 195.JAVEED A AND NAHEED J MERCHANT

  196. 196.HARISH T MANUJA

  197. 197.GAJARA SHYAM B

  198. 198.MOHD A K I AHMED KHAN

  199. 199.RAJESH B AND RAMESH B NAGPAL

  200. 200.VIJAY TRADING CO.

  201. 201.RAMCHAND K VIJLA

  202. 202.JAVEED A MERCHANT

  203. 203.JETHANAND BULCHAND

  204. 204.MEHBOO SHAIKH

  205. 205.MITRA STORES

  206. 206.AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI

  207. 207.AZIZ ABUBAKKA BHAWANI

  208. 208.GOKULDAS PHERUMAL

  209. 209.SHAIKH RAEES A AND SHAIKH S A

  210. 210.ISAJANDAS KEWALRAMI ESQ

  211. 211.VINOD V AND MONA V NAGPAL

  212. 212.N. AEWANDRAM N. VACANI

  213. 213.NANDLAL N. MUTREJA

  214. 214.OMPRAKASH JAIRAMDAS KHORMAL

  215. 215.GOKALDAS PHERULAL ESQ

  216. 216.R. DAMOMAL

  217. 217.NASREEN TEXTILES

  218. 218.PREM'S

  219. 219.SELETION SILK HOUSE

  220. 220.PRAKASH NEWANDRAM VENGANI

  221. 221.CHANDRA TRIKAMDAS

  222. 222.SHRIJRAM J. PUNJABI

  223. 223.SAWLARAM AND K S MALI

  224. 224.LEKHWAJ ASSUDOMAL

  225. 225.ABDUL GAFFER ABDUL KARIM

  226. 226.GOPIBAI D AND P HOLCHAND

  227. 227.JANKI NICHALDAS

  228. 228.DHULAMAL BROTHERS

  229. 229.ABDUL ALEEM CHUNNUMIYA MANIYAR

  230. 230.N.B.M. QURESHI AND S.A.B. MANDAI

  231. 231.MOHANDAS AWTRAM ESQ

  232. 232.MULCHAND KARMZMAL CHUGH

  233. 233.GOKULDAS PHERUMAL

  234. 234.NATIONAL STORES

  235. 235.SURESH V BHATIA

  236. 236.HAYAT

  237. 237.KHUBCHAND SEWARAM

  238. 238.KISHANCHAND DASMAL

  239. 239.PARTABHAI MITHUMAL ESQ

  240. 240.RIJHUMAL AND CO.

  241. 241.S.N. NARIWALA

  242. 242.DUNDERDAS AND ATMARAM J PUNJABI

  243. 243.LOVLY SILK HOUSE

  244. 244.RAMCHAND SONS

  245. 245.CHANDOO

  246. 246.RAJULA AND ROHIT LALCHANDANI

  247. 247.ISMAIL MA AIBANI AND A R HASHAM

  248. 248.RAMESH STORES

  249. 249.FARIDA EBRAHIM BADSHAH

  250. 250.L.K. ANANDINI

  251. 251.MATLOOB REHMAN

  252. 252.MEHRUNNISSA A R MANIYAR

  253. 253.MOHD. IMTIAZ HAJI AGEWAN

  254. 254.CHELA RAM KEWAL RAM P. SHANKAR

  255. 255.RITU SHARVAN GIRI

  256. 256.ISMAIL BILAL KAPADIA

  257. 257.LAVIN AND HITESH TAHILIANI

  258. 258.MASHKORR AHMED FAROOQUI

  259. 259.CHELARAM M. RAJNANI

  260. 260.A GAFFAR BHARUCHI

  261. 261.SANGITA R JETHANANI

  262. 262.SHAIKH R AHMED AND SHABBIR AHMED

  263. 263.LALCHAND AND BROTHERS

  264. 264.FANCY BHIMRAJI BAGERCHA

  265. 265.MOHD YAQOB MEHMOOD MIYA QURES

  266. 266.SAYYED BAKER

  267. 267.RAM CLOTH STORES

  268. 268.H.A. JABBAR

  269. 269.ALI AHMED SIDDIQUE

  270. 270.PREM ISRANI

  271. 271.MOHD SIDDIQUE S/O HAJI A

  272. 272.LACHHAMANDAS AND SONS

  273. 273.SALIM AHMED SORATHIA

  274. 274.ZULFIKAR KAYUMALI UDAIPURWALA

  275. 275.ZAIBUNISA MOHAMED IQBAL ADVANI

  276. 276.DILSHAD BEGUM MOHD RASHEED

  277. 277.BUSINESS TRACKERS, PRATHAMESH CHS LTD.

Case History

  1. Case disposedDisposed

  2. 07-May-2026

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. MarneView PDF

    Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

  3. 23-Apr-2026

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. MarneView PDF

  4. 23-Apr-2026

    For Circulation

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. Marne

  5. 21-Apr-2026

    Case filed

    Registration No. WP/5498/2026

casestatus.in Summary

Case Summary: WP/5498/2026 The Bombay High Court partly allowed the writ petition challenging the trial court's order directing a Court Commissioner to conduct an inspection of the suit building without the sanctioned architectural plan. The court found that since the Municipal Corporation could not provide the sanctioned plan (which was a prerequisite for the inspection order), the inspection would be futile—particularly for identifying unauthorized additions, alterations, and encroachments. Instead, the court directed defendants to provide plaintiffs with building details (unit numbers, areas, tenant names, and rental amounts) within two weeks, eliminating the need for the inspection and expediting the delayed eviction suit. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Explore other courts

District Courts Supreme Court
Search Another Case