SHRI. BABU CHANGYA PATIL (DEAD) AND OTHERS(Legal Heir) PRASAD S. DANI, P.S. DANI FOR PETITIONER,(V. P. for Appellant),VP FOR APPELLANT,Jui Arvind Nerurkar,PRASAD B KULKARNI,Anand S Patil1. vs SMT. BHAGIBAI PHULAJI MHASKER (DEAD) AND OTHERS — SA/513/2013

Case under C.p.c.- (Non-interlocutory Order). Disposed: Contested--Dismissed on 27th April 2026.

Case disposed Next hearing 10-May-2013

CNR: HCBM010152762013

Filing Number

SA/10757/2013

Filing Date

04-Apr-2013

Registration No

SA/513/2013

Registration Date

19-Aug-2013

Judge

Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

Coram

Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

Bench Type

Single

Category

SUITS ( 38 )

Sub-Category

FOR PARTITION ( 5 )

Judicial Branch

Civil

Decision Date

27-Apr-2026

Nature of Disposal

Contested--Dismissed

Last updated 24-May-2026

Acts & Sections

C.p.c.- (Non-interlocutory Order)
Indian Evidence Act
Registration Act, 1908

Petitioner(s)

  1. 1.SHRI. BABU CHANGYA PATIL (DEAD) AND OTHERS(Legal Heir) PRASAD S. DANI, P.S. DANI FOR PETITIONER,(V. P. for Appellant),VP FOR APPELLANT,Jui Arvind Nerurkar,PRASAD B KULKARNI,Anand S Patil1.

  2. 2.NANUBAI BABU PATIL (DEAD)1.

  3. 3.KAMALAKAR BABU PATIL1.

  4. 4.MADHUKAR BABU PATIL1.

  5. 5.GULAB BALKRUSHNA THAKUR1.

  6. 6.TARABAI TRIMBAK PORAJI1.

  7. 7.CHANDRAKANT CHANDRASHEKHAR THAKUR1.

  8. 8.MANDABI HASURAM THAKUR1.

  9. 9.VITHABAI BALKRUSHNA GAVAND (DEAD)1.8.

  10. 10.MANISH BALKRUSHNA GAVAND1.8.

  11. 11.SANTOSH BALKRUSHNA GAVAND1.8.

  12. 12.SANDESH BALKRUSHNA GAVAND1.

  13. 13.RADHABAI CHANDRAKANT PATIL1.

  14. 14.GAYATRI GANPAT MHATRE

  15. 15.GULAB BALKRUSHNA THAKUR

Respondent(s)

  1. 1.SMT. BHAGIBAI PHULAJI MHASKER (DEAD) AND OTHERS

    Adv. V.P. FOR RESP. NO. 1 TO 7,R NO 1, 2, 3-1 TO 3-3, 4 TO 7, 8-1, 8-2, 11 TO 15,,18, 20, 21 ARE SERVED.,(V.P. for Resp. No. 12 to 16 &

  2. 2.,(V.P. for Resp. 8-1,8-2,9 &

  3. 3.,S.A. STAND ABATED AS AGAINST R.NO.19 VIDE REG. ,J.(II) ORDER DT. 11/3/2014.,SA STAND ABATED AS AGAINST EXPIRED R NO 12 VIDE,COURTS ORDER DT 20/10/15 & 26/10/15.,RESPONDENT NO. 12/1, TO 12/3,VIJAY SUHAS GHARAT,WARUNJIKAR UDAY PRAKASH,WARUNJIKAR UDAY PRAKASH 1123

  4. 4.SHRI KESHAV PHULAJI MHASKAR

  5. 5.SMT. RAJANI JAGANNATH THAKUR

  6. 6.SHRI HASURAM PHULAJI MHASKAR (DECD THR HEIRS)(Legal Heir)4.

  7. 7.SHRI RAJU HASURAM MHASKAR4.

  8. 8.KUM. POOJA HASURAM MHASKAR4.

  9. 9.KUM PRIYA HASURAM MHASKAR

  10. 10.SMT. JAYA RAJAN THAKUR

  11. 11.SMT. HIRAWATI BALARAM PATIL

  12. 12.SHRI NARAYAN DEEPAK THAKUR

  13. 13.SMT. LILAVATI MANGESH MHATRE

  14. 14.SHRI GANANATH BHARAT PATIL (DEAD)(Legal Heir)9.

  15. 15.SHARAD GANANATH PATIL9.

  16. 16.SARITA ESARAM MHATRE

  17. 17.SAU. KRISHNABAI GOPINATH BIRJE

  18. 18.SMT. ANUTAI KASHINATH PATIL (DEAD)

  19. 19.SAU. SHAILA SHANTARAM GHARAT

  20. 20.SHRI JANBA DEVBA PATIL

  21. 21.SHRI DHANESHWAR DEVBA PATIL

  22. 22.SHRI NIVRUTTI DEVBA PATIL

  23. 23.SHRI VIJAY DEVBA PATIL

  24. 24.SHRI KHUSHAL DEVBA PATIL (DEAD)

  25. 25.SMT. LAXMIBAI DEVBA PATIL (DEAD)

  26. 26.SAU. HIRABAI ANANT GHARAT

  27. 27.MAHENDRA PRATAP SINGH

  28. 28.SMT. SHARADA PRATAP SINGH

  29. 29.SMT. JAYA PRAKASH SINGH

Case History

  1. Case disposedDisposed

  2. 27-Apr-2026

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

    Court Decision Summary The Bombay High Court dismissed the second appeal and upheld the first appellate court's judgment granting the plaintiff a 1/3 share in ancestral joint family properties. The court rejected the defendants' claim that unregistered partition documents proved Sitaram (the plaintiff's father) had relinquished his share, finding that the documents' contents were never proven through oral evidence and that mere separate possession could not establish a valid partition by metes and bounds. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

  3. 27-Apr-2026

    For Admission

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  4. 15-Apr-2026

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  5. 26-Aug-2025

    For Orders (Due Matters)

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Madhav J. Jamdar

  6. 22-Jul-2025

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Madhav J. JamdarView PDF

  7. 22-Jul-2025

    For Settlement / Consent Terms

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  8. 28-Apr-2025

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  9. 28-Apr-2025

    -Admission

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  10. 10-Mar-2025

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  11. 10-Mar-2025

    For Settlement / Consent Terms

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  12. 12-Feb-2025

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  13. 12-Feb-2025

    For Settlement / Consent Terms

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  14. 22-Jan-2025

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  15. 22-Jan-2025

    For Admission

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  16. 17-Dec-2024

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  17. 17-Dec-2024

    For Orders (Due Matters)

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri Godse

  18. 11-Jun-2024

    Hon'ble Ms. Justice Gauri GodseView PDF

  19. 11-Jun-2024

    For Admission

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. Deshmukh

  20. 16-Apr-2024

    For Admission

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. Deshmukh

  21. 02-Apr-2024

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. DeshmukhView PDF

  22. 02-Apr-2024

    For Orders (Due Matters)

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. Deshmukh

  23. 22-Mar-2024

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. DeshmukhView PDF

  24. 22-Mar-2024

    For Circulation

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. Deshmukh

  25. 01-Mar-2024

    Hon'ble Justice Sharmila U. DeshmukhView PDF

  26. 27-Sep-2019

    For Hearing amp Final Disposal CIVIL Side Matters

    According To Sitting List

  27. 24-Jun-2016

    For Orders [Civil Side Matters]

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Nitin Jamdar

  28. 17-Jun-2016

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Nitin JamdarView PDF

  29. 17-Jun-2016

    For Orders [Civil Side Matters]

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Nitin Jamdar

  30. 02-Apr-2016

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Nitin JamdarView PDF

  31. 02-Apr-2016

    For Admission - After Notice [Civil Side Matters]

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Nitin Jamdar

  32. 26-Oct-2015

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. TatedView PDF

  33. 20-Oct-2015

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. TatedView PDF

  34. 20-Oct-2015

    For Admission - After Notice CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. Tated

  35. 06-Oct-2015

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. TatedView PDF

  36. 06-Oct-2015

    For Admission - After Notice CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. Tated

  37. 29-Jul-2015

    For Admission

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravi K. Deshpande

  38. 11-Mar-2014

    —View PDF

  39. 11-Feb-2014

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)View PDF

  40. 11-Feb-2014

    For Orders

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)

  41. 19-Nov-2013

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. TatedView PDF

  42. 19-Nov-2013

    For Admission - Fresh CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice K.K. Tated

  43. 22-Oct-2013

    For Admission - Fresh CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice S.S. Shinde

  44. 04-Oct-2013

    For Admission - Fresh CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice S.S. Shinde

  45. 21-Sep-2013

    For Admission - Fresh CIVIL Side Matters

    Hon'ble Shri Justice S.S. Shinde

  46. 05-Jul-2013

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)View PDF

  47. 05-Jul-2013

    For Orders

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)

  48. 21-Jun-2013

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)View PDF

  49. 21-Jun-2013

    For Orders

    Registrar(judicial II Sa)

  50. 10-May-2013

    First hearing

    Initial hearing scheduled

  51. 04-Apr-2013

    Case filed

    Registration No. SA/513/2013

casestatus.in Summary

Court Decision Summary The Bombay High Court dismissed the second appeal and upheld the first appellate court's judgment granting the plaintiff a 1/3 share in ancestral joint family properties. The court rejected the defendants' claim that unregistered partition documents proved Sitaram (the plaintiff's father) had relinquished his share, finding that the documents' contents were never proven through oral evidence and that mere separate possession could not establish a valid partition by metes and bounds. This case analysis is maintained by casestatus.in based on publicly available court records.

Explore other courts

District Courts Supreme Court
Search Another Case